|
Mohammed
Image Archive
Depictions of
Mohammed Throughout History
07
February, 2006
Controversy over
the publication of images depicting Mohammed in the Danish
newspaper Jyllands-Posten has erupted into an international
furor. While Muslims worldwide are calling for a boycott of
Denmark and any other nation whose press reprints the cartoons,
Europeans are trying to stand up for Western principles of freedom
of speech and not cave in to self-censorship in the name of
multiculturalism and fear.
While the debate rages, an important point has been overlooked:
despite the Islamic prohibition against depicting Mohammed under
any circumstances, hundreds of paintings, drawings and other
images of Mohammed have been created over the centuries, with nary
a word of complaint from the Muslim world. The recent cartoons in
Jyllands-Posten are nothing new; it's just that no other
images of Mohammed have ever been so widely publicized.
This page is an archive of numerous depictions of Mohammed, to
serve as a reminder that such imagery has been part of Western and
Islamic culture since the Middle Ages -- and to serve as a
resource for those interested in freedom of _expression.
The images in the archive below have been divided into the following
categories:
Islamic
Paintings and Miniatures Showing Mohammed in Full
Islamic Depictions of Mohammed with Face Hidden
European Medieval and Renaissance Images
Book Illustrations
Dante's Inferno
French Book Covers
Various Eras
Contemporary Christian Drawings
Animated TV Parodies
Satirical Modern Cartoons
The Jyllands-Posten Cartoons
Recent Responses to the Controversy
Links
(Please note that the Arabic name
"Mohammed" has over the years been transliterated into Western
languages with several different spellings -- some of which you'll
encounter below -- including Mahomet, Muhammad, and Mohamed.)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Islamic Paintings and Miniatures
Showing Mohammed in Full
Medieval Muslim artists often created paintings and illuminated
manuscripts depicting Mohammed in full. Several examples are
presented here. Other artists of the era drew Mohammed but left
his face blank so as to technically comply with the Islamic ban on
depicting the Prophet; these images are shown in the second
section.
Persian or central Asian illustration showing Mohammed (on the
right) preaching.
Miniature of Mohammed re-dedicating the Black Stone at the Kaaba.
From Jami Al-Tawarikh ("The Universal History" written by
Rashid Al-Din), a manuscript in the Library of the University of
Edinburgh; illustrated in Tabriz, Persia, c. 1315.
(Hat tip: Brett K.)
The Ascension of the Prophet, also from Jami Al-Tawarikh
("The Universal History").
Mohammed on his prayer rug; Persia, late medieval (date unknown).
Mohammed meets the prophets Ismail, Is-hak and Lot in paradise.
From the Apocalypse of Muhammad, written in 1436 in Herat,
Afghanistan (now in the Bibliotheque Nationale, Paris).
(Hat tip for this image and the
image below: Buck.)
Mohammed arrives on the shores of the White Sea. Also from the
Apocalypse of Muhammad, written in 1436 in Herat, Afghanistan
(now in the Bibliotheque Nationale, Paris).
Fourteenth-century Persian miniature showing the Angel Gabriel
speaking to Mohammed.
Mohammed at Medina, from an Arab or central Asian medieval-era
manuscript.
Mohammed Received by the Four Angels; Persia, 1436.
Close-up of a medieval-era drawing showing Mohammed preaching,
along with a Christian-style halo.
A medieval illustration showing Mohammed (on the right). Source
unknown.
Image of angels holding the baby Mohammed. Source unknown.
(Hat tip: Nils.)
Mohammed's death. Source unknown.
Three
more
images of the full Mohammed can be found here
(Hat tip:
No Pasaran!, foreign
devil and Dusty).
Islamic Depictions of Mohammed with
Face Hidden
The Prophet Mohammed in a Mosque. Turkish, 16th Century, painting
on paper. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. The artist depicted
Mohammed in very long sleeves so as to avoid showing his hands,
though his neck and hints of his features are visible.
(Hat tip: Brett K.)
This is a miniature from Siyer-i Nebi, an Turkish religious
biography of Mohammed
completed in 1388 and later lavishly illustrated with 814
miniatures under the reign of Ottoman ruler Murad III, being
completed in 1595. Many of the miniatures depict Mohammed, and
this particular one shows Ali bin Abu Taleb beheading Nasr bin al-Hareth
in the presence of Mohammed and his companions.
Newly born Muhammad in his mother's arms being shown to his
grandfather and Meccans. From Turkish book painting (date
unknown). University of California, San Diego.
(Hat tip: Brett K.)
Islamic image of the Qur'an being revealed to Mohammed during a
battle.
Indonesian allegorical scene of Mohammed riding a mythical beast
-- possibly a depiction of his "Night Voyage."
Mohammed praying at the Ka'aba in Mecca. Turkish miniature from
the Ottoman Empire; date unknown.
(Hat tip: S.)
The Ascent of Mohammed, as depicted in a Persian manuscript.
Opaque watercolor and gold on paper, c. 1570. From the collection
of the Fine Arts Museum of San Francisco. Mohammed upon his winged
steed al-Burak ascending into heaven.
(Hat tip: Brett K.)
Mohammed (with face not visible) lying (possibly dead) in a
grotto, with anachronistic Mongol warriors looking on.
Indian or Asian painting of Mohammed receiving visions.
Mohammed astride a mythological beast; provenance unknown.
Mohammed preaching. Origin unknown.
(Hat tip: S.)
Mohammed ascending to Paradise.
Mohammed (face not visible) in an illustration of an episode from
the Qur'an.
Additional links to online images of
Mohammed with his face hidden (hat
tip: Rune):
Angels visit Muhammad to prepare him for the Miraj. Detail from
The Progress of the Prophet, Turkey, 16th century.
Ascent of the Prophet to Heaven. Persia, 1550.
(Another) Ascent of the Prophet to Heaven. Persia, 1550.
Muhammad on Buraq. Persia, mid-16th century.
Muhammad and Abu Bakr visit poor Bedouins.
The book
The Legacy of Jihad features an illustration of
Mohammed (sitting alone, to the right, his face covered) observing
the massacre of the Jewish tribe the Banu Qurayzah; from a
19th-century Kashmiri illustration in the British Library.
European Medieval and Renaissance
Images
Medieval and Renaissance Christian and secular artists had no
religious restrictions regarding depictions of Mohammed, and were
free to show his face and body in their entirety.
Mohammed preaching, from a medieval illuminated manuscript, with
historically inaccurate landscape and clothing (a common problem
in medieval and Renaissance paintings, which usually showed
fashions that were contemporary with the time the painting was
made, rather than showing the costumes of the era depicted).
This picture is of an early Renaissance fresco in Bologna's Church
of San Petronio, created by Giovanni da Modena and depicting
Mohammed being tortured in Hell.
(Hat tip: brenda.)
In 2002,
Islamic extremists plotted to blow up the church in order to
destroy the image.
The fresco is in an inaccessible part of the church and is now
only visible at an angle from a distance; this old black-and-white
image is one of the few official photos ever taken that shows a
straight frontal view of the figures.
Colored Renaissance print showing Mohammed at court, with wildly
inaccurate fashions.
The following two peculiar line drawings show Mohammed dressed in
Renaissance-era German garb and not behaving as one might expect:
"His Wife Scolding the Drunken Mohammed," German woodcut print, c.
1481. Source (for this image and the one below): The
Illustrated Bartsch. Vol. 83, German Book Illustration before
1500: Anonymous Artists, 1481-1482. Series title: Reysen
und Wanderschaften durch das Gelobte Land / Travels and Wanderings
Through the Holy Land. Presumably Mohammed is cursing the
vines for producing the grapes that got him drunk.
(Hat tip for this image and for
the following image: Brett K.)
"Mohammed Cursing the Vines," German woodcut print, c. 1481.
Book Illustrations
Many popular American and European books about Islam from the
18th, 19th and early 20th centuries included lithographs and line
drawings depicting Mohammed. Here is a small sampling:
Frontispiece from The Life of Mahomet, published 1719.
This illustration is taken from La vie de Mahomet, by M.
Prideaux, published in 1699. It shows Mohammed holding a sword and
a crescent while trampling on a globe, a cross, and the Ten
Commandments.
(Hat tip: Andy B.)
Death of Mahomet; photograph of a page in the book The History
of the Arabs, Including the Life of Mohammed, by William Mavor
(published in New York in 1804).
(Hat tip: little old lady.)
The following five images are of line drawings depicting Mohammed
from various 19th-century books about Islam:
Dante's Inferno
In the Inferno chapter of Dante's trilogy The Divine
Comedy, Mohammed is described as being one of the "Sowers of
Discord," showing his entrails to Dante and Virgil in the Eighth
Circle of Hell:
Inferno
XXVIII, 19-42.
The poets are in the ninth
chasm of the eighth circle, that of the Sowers of
Discord, whose punishment is to be mutilated.
Mahomet shows his entrails to Dante and Virgil
while on the left stands his son Ali, his head cleft
from chin to forelock.
Several famous artists have created their own illustrations of
this scene. In each drawing, Mohammed is the one with his torso
slit open.
Gustave Dor".
William Blake.
Auguste Rodin.
Salvador Dal.
The 1911 Italian silent film
L'Inferno contained a dramatization of the scene; Mohammed
is here on the right with his entrails hanging out.
(Hat tip: Peter R.)
French Book Covers
Several books about Islam published in France in the last 20 years
have unabashedly depicted Mohammed on their covers. None of them
caused any uproar or were noticed in the Muslim world at all.
Mahomet: la parole d'Allah, by Anne-Marie Delcambre.
Mahomet, by Salah St"ti".
Mahomet, by Maxime Rodinson.
Nouveau Tintin comic book, May 17, 1977 edition.
A different edition of Mahomet, by Anne-Marie Delcambre.
Various Eras
There have been depictions of Mohammed in every era. Here are a
few from periods not covered in other categories:
The North Frieze on the Supreme Court building in Washington, DC
features a bas-relief sculpture of Mohammed, among several other
historical law-givers. He is in the center of this image holding a
curved scimitar; on the left is Charlemagne, and on the right is
Byzantine Emperor Justinian. You can download a detailed pdf of
the Supreme Court friezes
here. The urban legend site
Snopes.com has info about the frieze in this entry.
(Hat tip: js, C. Reb, and Matt R.)
1928 German advertisement for bouillon extract shows Gabriel
guiding Mohammed up to Allah.
(Hat tip: karmic inquisitor.)
Mohammed at Mecca, by Andreas Muller, late 19th century; this is a
photogravure reproduction printed in 1889; the original is in the
Maximilianeum Gallery, Munich. Mohammed is the one on the camel,
and is depicted casting the idols out of the Kaaba.
(Hat tip: little old lady and
Andrew.)
Color print of Mohammed in anachronistic 17th- or 18th-century
garb.
Modern-era painting showing Mohammed. Artist unknown.
Recent issue of French magazine Le Nouvel Obervateur with
Mohammed on the cover. The current issue has
coverage of the Muslim reaction to the Danish cartoons but
makes no mention of their own Mohammed cover.
This 20th-century painting from a Shriners' Hall in Maine shows
Mohammed receiving a vision.
Another Shriners' painting showing Mohammed (in the red robe on
the right) being comforted by his uncle as he hides from Meccans
during his flight to Medina.
Iranian woman artist
Oranous (who is a Muslim and lives in Tehran) created
this iconic painting of a young Mohammed and is selling it
online. Though this would seem to violate Islamic and Iranian law,
an expert in Iranian Shi'ite customs writes in to say that this
particular painting is not forbidden because it depicts a young
Mohammed before he was visited by the Angel Gabriel and
started receiving his visions, which means that at this stage in
his life he is not yet the Prophet.
(Hat tip: baldy.)
[Note: What became of the other Iranian icons that used to be
on this page? Several readers emailed to say that the few
modern icons from Iran (formerly visible here) that supposedly
depicted Mohammed in fact depicted his cousin Ali, who is
considered the founder of the Shi'ite branch of Islam. The sites
from which these pictures were obtained -- The University of
Bergen and Jyllands-Posten -- misattributed the images by
accident. Our research indicates that it was indeed most likely
Ali in the icons, so we apologize for the mix-up. Click
here to see the most well-known of these icons (still
misidentified as Mohammed) on the Jyllands-Posten site.]
(Hat tip: Takin, Darmin, and Paul
C.)
Contemporary Christian Drawings
Some modern evangelical Christian groups have created biographies
of Mohammed as part of their proselytizing materials. Many of
these brochures and booklets contain drawings of Mohammed at
various points in his life. Here is a sampling:
Mohammed getting romantic with Khadijah, who would become his
first wife.
Mohammed receiving a vision in a cave. These two panels are among
many depicting Mohammed to be found in Jack Chick's 1988 booklet
The Prophet. The tract is quite long -- Mohammed
doesn't make an appearance until
page 13 (as a pawn in a convoluted historical conspiracy).
(Hat tip: baldy.)
This painting was originally done by Russian symbolist painter and
Theosophist
Nicholas Roerich in 1932, and is entitled "Mohammed the
Prophet," showing Mohammed receiving a vision. It has appeared in
the literature of various Christian groups.
(Hat tip: David B., Aquarius, and
Nicholas.)
Contemporary stylized drawing of Mohammed.
This reproduction is a bit small, but it shows Mohammed destroying
the idols at the Kaaba in Mecca. It is not a Christian
illustration exactly, but rather is taken from Manly P. Hall's
occult guide The Secret Teachings of All Ages, which
incorporates ideas from many religions, Christianity (and Islam)
among them.
(Hat tip: MikalM.)
Animated TV Parodies
The television cartoon South Park aired an episode on July
4, 2001 called
Super Best Friends. In it, the founders of the world's
great religions -- including Mohammed -- team up for super-hero
action. Mohammed (seen here) is depicted repeatedly throughout the
show. The entire episode can be viewed online
here.
(Hat tip: Dayenu and Alouette.)
Spike TV created a parody advertisement for an imaginary video
game called Holy War, featuring religious icons battling to
the death. One of the characters is Mohammed, who is shown first
defeating Joseph Smith...
...and then getting beaten by Moses, who cuts off his head with
the Ten Commandments. You can view a streaming video of the
Holy War ad
at this
site.
(Hat tip: Andrew.)
Satirical Modern Cartoons
A few contemporary cartoonists have ignored any potential threats
and created satirical and/or mocking cartoons about Mohammed.
The caption to
this cartoon by Steph Bergol says, in French:
Mohammed (being carried away by devils): "It is a judicial error!
I am Mohammed, the prophet!"
St. Peter (with a scimitar through his chest): "Definitely:
GUILTY!"
(Several other
cartoons by Bergol on a similar theme can be found
here.)
(Hat tip: thierry.)
This panel is one of hundreds satirizing Mohammed in the humorous
cartoon biography called
Mohammed's
Believe It or Else! by pseudonymous artist "Abdullah Aziz."
(Click to see the full biography; the images there are
copyrighted, so they can't be reprinted on other Web sites.)
A Dutch Web site called
Pret
Met Mohammed (loosely translated as "Fun With Mohammed")
features a series of politically incorrect cartoons. Three of the
Pret Met Mohammed cartoons are presented here; click on the link
above for a few more and for English translations of the Dutch
word balloons.
In 1997, an Israeli woman named
Tatiana Soskin drew this caricature of Mohammed as a pig
authoring the Koran and tried to display it in public in the city
of Hebron. She was arrested, tried and sentenced to jail.
(Hat tip: helloworld.)
In 2002, political cartoonist Doug Marlette published this drawing
of Mohammed driving a truck with a nuclear bomb.
(Hat tip: Thomas G.)
In 2002, the French publication Charlie Hebdo ran this
panel by cartoonist Cabu. The sign translates as "Election of Miss
Sack-of-Potatoes, organized by Mohammed," who chooses his favorite
while drinking and smoking.
(Hat tip: Etienne P.)
The Jyllands-Posten Cartoons
The Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten created the furor over
depictions of Mohammed by publishing a series of 12 drawings after
a local author said he was unable to find any artist willing to
depict Mohammed for his upcoming illustrated book. The publication
of the images in Jyllands-Posten has been condemned around
the Islamic world, and has led to calls for a boycott of Denmark
by Muslim nations.
Here are the Jyllands-Posten drawings, for the record:
Higher-resolution jpegs of each individual cartoon, along with a
picture of the article on the original Jyllands-Posten
page, can be found
here.
Furthermore, when a delegation of Danish imams went to the Middle
East to
discuss the issue of the cartoons with senior officials and
prominent Islamic scholars, the imams openly distributed a
booklet that showed not only the original 12 cartoons, but three
fraudulent anti-Mohammed depictions that were much more offensive
than the ones published in Denmark. It is now thought that
these three bonus images are what ignited the outrage in the
Muslim world. The newspaper Ekstra Bladet
obtained a copy of the booklet and presented the three
offensive images on its Web site (though not in an easy-to-find
place). All look like low-quality photocopies. Here they are:
(Hat tip: Gerry, Martin H., and
rfs.)
Mohammed with a pig snout, singing into a microphone. (Link to
original source file at Ekstra Bladet is temporarily
overloaded.)
The caption says in Arabic, "This is why Muslims pray." (Link
to original source file at Ekstra Bladet is temporarily
overloaded.)
(Hat tip: Daniel and Ken.)
A sketch of Mohammed as a demonic pedophile. (Link to original
source file at Ekstra Bladet is temporarily overloaded.)
The entire controversy started when Danish author Kre Bluitgen
complained that he could not find an artist brave enought to
illustrate his upcoming book about Mohammed. The newspaper
Jyllands-Posten issued a call for submissions from any artists
willing to take up the challenge. In the ensuing brouhaha, the
original book was almost forgotten; it has now been released, and
does feature page after page of Mohammed depictions.
This site features scans of several of the pages
(hat tip: Rune, Kim and Mikkel.).
This image above, taken from the book (titled Koranen og
profeten Muhammeds liv, or The Koran and the life of the
prophet Mohammed in English), apparently shows Mohammed with
his child-bride Aisha.
This Danish blog also has some information about the release
of the book.
Recent Responses to the Controversy
Filibuster cartoons features a new comic that really hits the
nail on the head.
(Hat tip:
Ole and Benjamin.)
Several artists (both professional and amateur) have created their
own responses to the controversy over the Danish cartoons. Many of
the artists expressed their mockery of and disdain for the Muslim
world's violent reaction with new Mohammed depictions that are
intentionally direspectful and/or obscene, to make a point about
freedom of speech. If you are easily offended, you might want to
stop reading here.
Steve D., the proprietor of
this blog, fashioned his own statement about the controversy
by Photoshopping one of the Jyllands-Posten drawings onto
the rear end of a camel.
(Hat tip:
Rant
Wraith.)
On February 1, France Soir newspaper published this cartoon
on its cover, caricaturing Mohammed equally with other religious
figures.
(Hat tip: Gathers.)
On February 3, Le Monde newspaper published this cartoon on
its front page -- a drawing of Mohammed composed of sentences that
say "Je ne dois pas dessiner Mahomet," or "I should not draw
Mohammed."
(Hat tip: John and
Erik.)
The Study of Revenge blog featured this uncompromising image
by D. T. Devareaux.
(Hat tip: JHW.)
The Crybaby Mohammed.
(Hat tip: Buck.)
The
"Jesus and Mo" comic strip showed one of Mohammed's testicles.
Mohammed offers some Koranic wisdom about meddlesome artists in
the
"Mohammed the Prophet Answers Your Emails" cartoon strip.
This Czech Web site
featured an artist's three responses to the controversy. This one
shows Mohammed as a nude suicide bomber, with his six-year-old
bride Aisha on the right.
This one shows Mohammed as a pig, apparently (?) being inspired by
the Devil.
And this is a more traditional portrait.
Several postmodern satirists have highlighted the point that --
since no one really knows what Mohammed looked like -- any
image could be said to depict him. To that end, they have
captioned photos of their thumbs or rudimentary stick figures as
"Mohammed." This image -- of a generic figure from the Danish toy
company Lego, identified as being Mohammed -- is a good example of
the
genre.
(Hat tip: darmin.)
MSNBC political cartoonist Daryl Cagle emphasized the point with
this response to the story, which includes a stick-figure
Mohammed.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you know of any other interesting depictions of Mohammed
that you think should be included on this page, email suggestions
here.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Media Coverage
On February 2, 2006, the BBC broadcast a televised news segment
featuring pictures and information from the Mohammed Image
Archive.
Click here to see a short QuickTime mpeg video of the
broadcast:
Reporter:
"This Islamic scholar says the crucial injunction in the Koran is
against mocking the Prophet, or other authorities."
Sheikh Haitham al-Haddad: "It's totally prohibited to do
something that belittle the prophets of Allah, and depiction is
part of belittling the prophets of Allah, from one['s] anger.
[Printed-out pages of the Mohammed Image Archive shown being
placed on a table.]
Reporter: "Traditionally, Islam has frowned on any
representations of living beings. But painters in Islamic
countries have depicted Mohammed for centuries."
[Close-up of
this image from above showing a medieval Islamic depiction of
Mohammed.]
Reporter: "Despite official disapproval, portraits of the
Prophet are sold to devout Muslims in Iran today."
[Close-up of
this image from above showing Iranian portrait.]
Sheikh Haitham al-Haddad: "Some people have a Muslim name,
and they claim that, oh, they might have Muslim parents, but they
have left Islam totally."
Reporter: "But [gesturing toward Mohammed Image Archive
pages] these are from, these are from medieval Persia, from the
medieval Ottoman Empire, so surely they're Muslims."
Sheikh Haitham al-Haddad: "No, not necessarily. Islam is a
practice. It is not just a claim. Islam is a way of life. So, we
practice Islam in our daily life in every inch and each aspect.
It's not just a claim and then we can do whatever we want. No."
Reporter: "So [pointing to Mohammed Image Archive pages]
these pictures were wrong."
Sheikh Haitham al-Haddad: "Of course. Hundred percent
wrong."
(Hat tip: bweep and Max Darkside.)
Article about this page in the February 1, 2006 edition of the
Ekstra Bladet newspaper in Denmark.
The Australian newspaper has copied the information off the
Mohammed Image Archive (which was not credited) in
an article entitled "Depictions of prophet nothing new,"
published on February 6, 2006.
(Hat tip: brenda.)
Links
Mirror sites:
(Note: Mirror sites do not contain
the latest updates to this page.)
info2us.dk
Beth
Outpost911
Nordish.net
Aaron's cc
Retecool
Anti-Semitic cartoons from contemporary Arab media.
In the Feburary 3, 2006 Der Spiegel, Ibn Warraq makes a
powerful argument for freedom of speech.
Mo
Parody's Mohammed Pics page has several Mohammed images not
included here.
Prescient monologue about Muslim oppression of free speech from
Beaumarchais' play The Marriage of Figaro, from 1784.
The Chester Beatty Library in Dublin has put up a display of
Mohammed images.
Many interesting political cartoons about the controversy from
artists around the world can be viewed in this post at
Daryl Cagle's Web Log.
Cox and Forkum snuck a Mohammed picture into their cartoon
about the controversy.
DailyKos post with links to and examples from the Mohammed
Image Archive, plus discussion of the Islamic tradition of
depicting Mohammed.
Irregular Times has some Mohammed cartoons and thoughts on the
situation.
Aaron's cc: Mohammed's Breakfast of Blasphemy
Iraqi children with a poster that includes a picture of Mohammed
at the Al-Huda squatter's camp, Baghdad.
CAGE
has a compilation of photos showing the reaction to the
publication of the cartoons.
As a point of comparison -- when these two artworks were widely
published around the world, there were no riots:
Andres Serrano's Piss Christ (photo of a crucifix in a jar of
urine).
Chris Ofili's "The Holy Virgin Mary" (made from paint and elephant
dung).
***Warning***: Links to Offensive
Satirical Mohammed Images Below
Belgian cartoon showing Mohammed's buttocks.
Three-way.
Four-way.
Piggy Mohammed.
Gregorius Nekschot's notorious cartoon of "Mohammed"
deflowering "Aisha" -- both depicted as middle-aged Russian
peasants.
Mohammed as Hitler.
(Click
here to return to the main zombietime page.)
|
|
|