Not Taliban but Islam is the real culprit behind attempted murder of Malala, because the Taliban is simply following the teachings of the Quran, Sunna of Muhammad and Sharia Law, which is religiously binding upon all Muslims.
![]() |
Malala Yousafzai – a very brave a 14-year-old school girl – was shot and badly wounded while boarding her school bus by a member of the Taliban.
What was her crime to deserve execution?
At the age of 13 years, she championed the cause of the people of Swat by blogging for the BBC under a pseudonym about the atrocities of the Tehrik-e-Taliban and other Islamic extremist groups. She stated that she wanted an education – her ambition was to be a doctor. She campaign for education and rights of women in the Pakistani tribal belt, where the Taliban have imposed education and work for women.
Courageous for a little girl she is, he was nominated for several awards, and became runner-up in the International Children's Peace Prize (Runner-up, 2011) and won the Pakistan National Peace Prize (2011).
The Taliban predictably declared her a symbol of obscenity and accused her of spreading negative propaganda for the Taliban. There on, she was targeted for extermination and she is fighting for her life.
Islam, not Taliban
Not Taliban but Islam is the real culprit behind attempted murder of Malala, because the Taliban is simply following the teachings of the Quran, Sunna of Muhammad and Sharia Law, which is religiously binding upon all Muslims.
Malala Yousafzai was a threat to Islam. By standing up for her human rights, and for the equality of women, and her human right to be free to decide her own future, Malala stood for the liberation of Muslim women. In other words, she was a symbol for the liberation of Muslim women, one-half of the Muslim populations, whose subjugation and repression is sanction by holy dictums of the Quran, Sunnah and Sharia.
![]() |
After Kafirs, Allah, the Islamic God, hates the Muslim women most. Indeed, their repression can be worse, because the infidels can simply pay jizya and other taxes, and live their own life. But Muslims women don’t have that liberty and humanity. The Quran sets up the intellectual frame work for their subjugation and repression. They are the property of Muslim men. They are deficient in intelligence. Muslim women are only baby factories for their husbands.
Here is a sample of Quranic verses, the word of God, that belittle, dehumanize and subjugate women to Muslim men.
- Sura (5:6) - "...if ye have had contact with women, and ye find not water, then go to clean, high ground and rub your faces and your hands with some of it." Women are polluting. Muslim men purify themselves following a casual contact with a woman.
- Sura (4:176) “They ask thee for a legal decision. Say: God directs (thus) about those who leave no descendants or ascendants as heirs. ... if there are brothers and sisters, (they share), the male having twice the share of the female.”
- Sura (4:34) - "Men are the maintainers of women because Allah has made some of them to excel others and because they spend out of their property; the good women are therefore obedient, guarding the unseen as Allah has guarded; and (as to) those on whose part you fear desertion, admonish them, and leave them alone in the sleeping-places and beat them; then if they obey you, do not seek a way against them; surely Allah is High, Great."
- Sura (2:228) - "And women shall have rights similar to the rights against them, according to what is equitable; but men have a degree (of advantage) over them. And God is Exalted in Power, Wise.”
- Sura (4:11) – “God (thus) directs you as regards your Children's (Inheritance): to the male, a portion equal to that of two females.” (see also Sura 4:176)
A husband has the legal right and religious obligation to beat a wife if she disobeys him, is disloyal to him or simply does not please him. The concept of wife abuse does not exist in Islam. According to Islamic law, a husband may strike his wife for any one of the following four reasons: (1) She does not attempt to make herself beautiful for him (i.e. "let's herself go"), (2) She refuses to meet his sexual demands, (3) She leaves the house without his permission or a "legitimate reason", and (4) She neglects her religious duties. Any of these are also sufficient grounds for divorce.
Sura (2:223) - "Your wives are as a tilth unto you; so approach your tilth when or how ye will." Wives are to be sexually available to their husbands in all ways at all times. They serve their husbands at his command.
MUSLIM WOMEN: ISLAM’S DOMESTIC ANIMALS
Great Islamic scholar and historian Al-Tabari writes (The History of al-Tabari, IX: 112-114):
“Now then, O people, you have a right over your wives and they have a right over you. You have [the right] that they should not cause anyone of whom you dislike to tread your beds, and that they should not commit any open indecency (fahishah). If they do, then God permits you to shut them in separate rooms and to beat them, but not severely. If they abstain from [evil], they have the right to their food and clothing in accordance with custom (bi’l-maruf). Treat women well, for they are [like] domestic animals (‘awan) with you and do not possess anything for themselves......”
Bukhari (6:301) writes on the deficiency in intelligence of Muslim women:
"[Muhammad] said, ‘Is not the evidence of two women equal to the witness of one man?' They replied in the affirmative. He said, 'This is the deficiency in her intelligence.'"
How dare Malala, a member of the subjugated female sex, that too a little girl dare fight for the rights and liberation of Pakistani women, and challenge the Taliban. She did get her deserving deserts. And the Taliban has threatened to target her again, if she survives.
What the Taliban does are not an aberration of Islam. Their actions represent Islam in truth. Malala is murdered by Islam.
--
Jake Neuman is the author of “Islam and Sharia Law Are Treason: Jihad Is Treason” and “Prophet Muhammad (AKA ALLAH): Monster of History.” (free download)

written by HARKAT UL JIHAD EI KAFIROOON , October 12, 2012
written by HARKAT UL JIHAD EI KAFIROOON , October 12, 2012
written by Malem , October 12, 2012
written by Montegue , October 12, 2012
Yes, women in Islam are more oppressed than the infidels. When they are rape, all they could do is wish that they don't get pregnant because to report the crime will only get her lashed in public, especially Koran demand 4 witnesses. Gang rape has enough witnesses but the gang will not testify against each other. In Saudi, a young woman must be accompanied by a male relative when traveling or commuting, but too often they were raped by the men. That happened to a Pakistani girl I know. She broke in tears when she receive a letter from her parent asking her return to marry her cousin because, as she admitted that, the guy raped her at very young age. She likes western men, we do it by mutual consent. That's why they enjoy us very much and dreaded Muslim men. In Islam women marry without love. Love without respect because rape within marriage is not considered rape.
written by ChrisLA , October 12, 2012
written by Walter Sieruk , October 12, 2012
Matthew 7:16-18. [KJV]
written by Jye , October 12, 2012
written by fineliving56 , October 12, 2012
The filthy cowered Muslims go after a 14 years old girl ? … no surprise
Adding salt to open wound … the filthy Muslim thugs said THIS when they heard that Malala seruvived and might live ..
'' WE WILL INSURE TO FINISHED HER NEXT TIME '' .. or to this effect
THAT'S MEANS THIS YOUNG WOMEN NEEDS A FULL TIME PROTECTION ALL HER LIFE TO INSURE HER SAFTY IF SHE LIVES
Hey Muslim defenders in here …
What you are going to do ?
Talk is cheap !
WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO TO TRY TO STOP YOUR BROTHERS WHO YOU SHAER ISLAM WITH, FROM GOING AFTER GIRLS IF THEY WANT TO LEARN ?
written by berq , October 13, 2012
written by Jimat Khorasan , October 13, 2012
While a Musalman is entitled to joyous sex with 70 virginal Houris & 2 of his 4 wives; in the promised Islamic Paradise, what benefits does a Musalma enjoy in Islamic Paradise?
Instead of draping themselves in dour chadors and hijabs, isn't it time that Musalmas take the standards from a brave female like Malala; to kick the arrogant, sexist, chauvinistic, insecure, paedophilic and brain dead Musalman between their legs and tell them to go f..... a camel!
Muslims will wake up to this evil visited upon Malala; and should question the morals and rules quoted by the Taliban from none other their own holy Islamic texts.
This is a historic moment in our world, because what we are witnessing is the beginning to the slow death of Islam; where Islam will destroy itself!
written by abc , October 13, 2012
The whole of Pakistan has condemned the attack. Men and women.
Chief of staff general kiyani has promised to bring the perps to justice.
The president and all the political parties have condemned the attack.
The people will be caught and justice will be done.
What we can do is add to the condemnation and use our influence to get some positive action from the people in power!
written by Kaser , October 13, 2012
Would you agree to be married to a woman with a husband already? - Be one of her two husbands?
Why not? If it's ok for a man to have two wives, why not a woman have two husbands?
written by Kaser , October 13, 2012
Muslim women will be the fall of Islam. Malala is a perfect example of this desire to unlatch themselves from oppression.
Look at Saudi Arabia. What a fu**ed-up country where women are something between cattle and humans.
Saudi males are not deserving of the word "men" they are cowards that, through force, lower their women...
And is not Saudi Arabia the "perfect Islamic State"
My hopes are with the millions of Muslim women FED UP with this religion-induced CRAP.
You will win. The cult will wither and die.
written by Dr R Brahmachari , October 13, 2012
written by HARKAT UL JIHAD EI KAFIROOON , October 13, 2012
i saw the light of truth in 1992 and left islam.now i preach truth abt jihadislam.
yes i hate muslims bcoz u people killed my indians for no reason other than islam.
i will shoot a muslim any time.
bcoz it gaurantees 720 virgins in real jannat.
written by berq , October 13, 2012
written by abc , October 13, 2012
So you have actually continued your joke posts.
The Taliban are not scholars Infact I suspect 99.9% cannot even read or write.
But you seem to hold them in high regard. Feel free to join them!
Of course it makes a difference if the whole of society condemn it, you simpleton.
What society are by default saying is that they reject the Taliban. The difference it will make hopefully is no more victims like the this young lass.
Education for women has been a must in Islam. It's only in the last century that things have gone a miss. But things are changing and I hope to see more and more Muslim women in education!
I could give you lots of referenced but like a hater you already ask me not to enlighten you.
written by abc , October 13, 2012
So some dude some centuries ago did some stuff.
That makes you hate your friends and neighbours because they share the same religion as him. Some would say that's the sign of an imbecile.
What says you????
He he!
written by abc , October 13, 2012
Im sure I've told you before. The Saudi state are traitors to Islam.
To equate Saudi Arabia to an Islamic state is a joke.
The Saudis state will fall and the will of the people will be done.
That includes all the other rag tag Arab states.
Already all the Arab states are feeling threatened ideologically and physically by a free Egypt!!
written by HARKAT UL JIHAD EI KAFIROOON , October 13, 2012
go to taliban and the saudi and teach them to treat women as equal not 1/2 as much as men.
written by annad , October 13, 2012
Yak!
written by Jye , October 13, 2012
Mohammed Mursi - “Nothing in the Constitution will supercede Islamic Sharia rule.”
And some more on "FREE" Egypt:-
http://www.egyptindependent.co...d-preacher
http://english.alarabiya.net/a...43221.html
http://www.egyptindependent.co...islam-post
http://www.copticsolidarity.or...-plundered
http://www.youtube.com/watch?f...JV84SBpP4k
http://edition.cnn.com/2012/07...index.html
http://www.youtube.com/watch?f...37qZX3OiqY
http://theantislave.wordpress....-marriage/
http://english.ahram.org.eg/News/46968.aspx
http://www.youtube.com/watch?f...04m4mr4aDQ
written by annad , October 13, 2012
We hear all kind of fatwas from islamic world allthe time. Most of them condone all kind of violence and indecency all the time. Isnt time for islmic clerics to issue some decree against obvious injustice?
The silence is too deafening.
written by def , October 13, 2012
Your ignorance is mind boggling.
Pakistan is not a theocratic state! The mullahs wield no power!
The people that matter have condemned it.
Maybe you should clean out your ears!
written by Walter Sieruk , October 13, 2012
Moreover, by his own actions this Taliban Muslim has proven that Brigitte Gabriel, the founder of actforamerica.com, was right and telling the truth when she wrote in her book THEY MUST BE STOPPED that "even in moderate Islamic countries, women's rights are almost nonexeistent...Women in Islam are considered unlcean inferior even to dirt."
written by Khadija , October 13, 2012
Ex-christianity says that eve ate the apple formt the forbidden tree and adam was punished for it too but Qur'an says that both ate apple and both got sent to the earth
Ex2-christianity says tht since woman brought men to earth so childbirth's pain is a punishment for them or something whereas Islam says that they get good points and rewards for the pain of childbirth.
Also,Islam gave women right to property 1400yrs ago.christianity about 100yrs ago was discussing whther women have souls!!!!!
oh and if u actually watched the news,u weould have known that everywhere muslims are condemning the attack.My references may not be related to ur stupid article bcoz it was so pathetic i couldnt read it fully.Infact,the first verse that was sent to prophet through an angel was "IQRA" which translates as "read" or "educate" and not"kill" or "hate"
why r u doing this,man??what will u get by hating on someone's religion?I respect all the religions and if u were a true follower if any religion,u would have known better.
peace
P.S.-if anyones religios sentiments were hurt by my comment,then i m really sorry for that was certainly not my intention,
written by Jye , October 13, 2012
Khadija, I hope you and your sister wives enjoy your freedom, and "rights to property" (half that of a male) under Islam, also contrary to what any "Christian" has ever spoken, there is no questioning to whether females have a soul within Christianity.
written by Liberal Fundamentalist , October 13, 2012
But first, a bit of introspection may be in order.
Just try marking out passages in your Koran and the hadiths which you feel aren’t in tune with your sensibilities. For starters, you can take the salacious bits about your Ol’ camel turd in the book of Bukhari and see if you can condone these, let alone approve of them. Nothing too special about them. Almost all religious/cultural texts have something of this nature (maybe not equaling Ol’ camel turd’s antics or even coming close) in them. But the difference is, anybody with an iota of sense can reject them, print and publish a version of their own choosing, follow it and get on with their life. But not so with Islam. You’re stuck with it and repudiating them would classify you as a heretic first class. And Islam has spawned enough nut-jobs to ensure that apostates remain an endangered species.
So don’t you carp about the tough time you’ve had on this website. Just cross out the offending’ passages and let a “friendly” neighborhood cleric know about it and we won’t be seeing you on this website any more.
written by ANNAD , October 14, 2012
It has nothing to do with being in power. Mullahs have moral authority and as such have a freedom to express their opinion, their judgement on all kind of things. They are often very vocal in different Muslim dominated states when it comes to incite the believers to violence against infidels. Now, I would like to hear some of the clerics to denounce this murder as "unislamic" as loudly as they speak about, lets say, evil of homosexuality.
written by ANNAD , October 14, 2012
Truly, you will know them by their fruits.
written by def , October 14, 2012
Are you eve upto date with the story??
Talking about something you know nothing about!
Typical
written by Gnostic , October 14, 2012
However, all this does not work! A modern society does not work with islam because anybody can point to the quranic verses and the hadith.
There might be some moderate or even progressive muslims, but there will never be a moderate or progressive islam. Allah is rendered in the quran as a monster, and many radical muslims are emulating him.
written by someone to Khadija , October 14, 2012
written by fineliving56 , October 14, 2012
written by def , October 14, 2012
Every time they threw up their best I am able to read and research a stronger argument. In many ways it's opened my eyes and made me a better Muslim.
written by Malawi , October 14, 2012
written by fineliving56 , October 14, 2012
but, you have NOT proven one darn thing of authenticity of Islam as TRUE word of God .
If the meaning of the word '' idrubuhuna'' that your non Arabic speaking imams have lied about, and you swallowed it as the truth '' is any indication of your '' strong argument, then you are have been deceived '
How could let lying Imams fool you like that ? .. Why don't you investigate for your self instead of believing these filthy greasy and two faced snakes imams ...
We have shut down every thing you guys brought from your strong armament, you have not been able to convince one infidel of Islam as true word of God like you claim .
I have an idea
Why don't you tell one of your imams to try to come here to refute, .one charge we have brought down on Quran//Muhammad amd Islam .
try it ... def/Abc
written by Demsci , October 14, 2012
"why r u doing this,man??what will u get by hating on someone's religion?"
Please do not only think of yourself and your community but about the future of all mankind. There may be something better for mankind than Islam. The website-owner thinks this and that is why he shows the shortcoming sides and the probable untruth of Islam.
You probably only heard and are interested in the good-feeling side of Islam. You probably are not open at all to a different and better belief and life-style than Islam.
For instance, Quran-Hadiths-Sira are supposed to be divine. And because of that they cannot be changed one word, nothing can be scrapped from them and nothing can be added to them. This is supposed to go on until judgment day. But it has been 1300-1400 years now since the holy texts came to the world and the world has since much changed. How much longer will the Muslims have to rely on the Quran-Hadiths-Sira unchanged???
If they had been supposed to be manmade, like the constitution and laws of democratic states, mankind would long since have changed, scrapped, improved and added words and laws to Quran-Hadiths-Sira so that they were better adapted to the times and there would be no misunderstanding and no quessing but almost universal agreement about what the texts mean and mean not and what they order muslims to do and not to do.
But Quran-Hadiths-Sira are now hopelessly unclear, incomplete, ambiguous, understood and practised in many different ways by Muslims. So naturally it is very possible that the Taliban, OR YOU, or both, misunderstand these holy texts, if you indeed have studied them well and complete and honest enough, which is doubtful with many Muslims.
And for the future of mankind it is best to show and warn mankind of these shortcomings of the Islamic holy texts, because there might be something better than Islam for future mankind!
Just as Muslims suppose that Islam was better than what came before it. But that means that somehow many people suffered because their belief, from before Islam, was being criticized and fought against by the early Muslims. In a way this website-owner revenges the adherents of previous religions that Islam condemned, fought, suppressed and replaced in the territories it is in now.
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 14, 2012
Did you see my 3 articles? Do you think they were moronic? Do you think me a hater? Do you think my ways are deceitful?
> Every time they threw up their best I am able to read and research a stronger argument. In many ways it's opened my eyes and made me a better Muslim.
Do you have criticisms of my ideas?
Here are my articles (also posted on this site) and below that is some discussion I had with a Muslim:
Is Allah real?
http://ramirustom.blogspot.com/2012/09/is-allah-real.html
Why Most Terrorists Are Muslims
http://ramirustom.blogspot.com/2012/09/why-most-terrorists-are-muslims.html
Why don’t Ex-Muslims go public?
http://ramirustom.blogspot.com/2012/09/why-dont-ex-muslims-go-public.html
I explain that punishment is immoral and that Islam is big on punishment. The Muslim says that punishment is not always bad and that Islam doesn't really explain to punish people.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Fabric-of-Reality/message/24913
That discussion took a tangent to sexism in Islam. He denied it.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Fabric-of-Reality/message/24954
That discussion took a tangent to the idea that Islam (and all religions) necessarily cause factions. And one of the Quranic verses is against factions, thus the Quran is self-contradictory.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Fabric-of-Reality/message/24984
One of those discussions took a tangent to the politics and history of Islam upon Mohamed's death. Actually many of the tangents touched on this point.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Fabric-of-Reality/message/24985
The sexism discussion touched on the this new rationalization that I've never heard from Muslims before: 7th century Arabs counting age from the age of mental maturity, so that he could deny that Mohamed married a pre-menstrual girl.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Fabric-of-Reality/message/24996
One of those discussions took a tangent to the idea that the Quran is consistent with modern science.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Fabric-of-Reality/message/25006
One of those discussions took a tangent to the idea that Islam criticism is equivalent to antisemitism.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Fabric-of-Reality/message/24953
written by Guy Macher , October 14, 2012
written by Guy Macher , October 14, 2012
written by Jye , October 14, 2012
written by def
Every time they threw up their best I am able to read and research a stronger argument. In many ways it's opened my eyes and made me a better Muslim.
And yet you rarely if ever shared these "stronger arguments" on the forum. Hmmm...
"A better Muslim" (that hasn't heard of the Sunnah) LOL
written by def , October 14, 2012
The sooner the Saudi government are tried as traitors then the better!
Clear?
written by def , October 14, 2012
I think he even included the verses.
Still you use it in isolation and insist you know what you are talking about!
How did that conversation end? I think someone screamed taqiyya and he just could be asked to take it further!
The same thing happened when we discussed your other favourite word "lam yahidna"
Why would I call anyone when you cannot convince anyone???
written by def , October 14, 2012
I'm sure you know the and read the rubbish ones.
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 14, 2012
So you don't have any criticisms of my ideas? Or is just that you don't want to post your criticisms?
If you don't criticize my ideas, then you take them as true. Note that one of my articles explained how knowledge is created. If an idea is left uncriticized, then it is considered the truth (for now, until someone in the future refutes it).
So which is? Do you have criticisms?
If so, please post them.
But if you don't have any criticisms, then why are you still a Muslim?
written by fineliving56 , October 14, 2012
Reed the non Arab convert to Islam has posted all the words of '' DARB '' in compounded form IN QURAN and and I REFUTED him in each case , AND THEN HE DID NOT COME BACK WITH A REFUTE after that I took it as, he was throughly DEFEATED … he did not come back with any criticism of my criticism .
He was wrong on the word '' Idrubuhuna '' in 4/34 … and I proved it , I will be happy to prove him wrong again and post the whole refute again .
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 14, 2012
Repeating an idea multiple times does not make an idea true.
> I think he even included the verses.
You think? So you're not sure?
> Still you use it in isolation and insist you know what you are talking about!
Because she does know.
> How did that conversation end? I think someone screamed taqiyya and he just could be asked to take it further!
You "think" again? So you're not sure.
> The same thing happened when we discussed your other favourite word "lam yahidna" Why would I call anyone when you cannot convince anyone???
Someone not getting convinced doesn't mean that the speaker is wrong. It can mean that the listener is an idiot.
written by fineliving56 , October 14, 2012
http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Beat_your_Wives_or_"Separate_from_Them"?_(Qur'an_4:34)
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 14, 2012
http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Beat_your_Wives_or_"Separate_from_Them"?_(Qur'an_4:34)
If you disagree with a part of that explanation that asserts that Quran 4:34 says for husbands to hit their wives, then that means you believe it has one or more flaws. So if that is the case, then quote the relevant text, point out the flaw, and explain why you think its flawed.
written by fineliving56 , October 14, 2012
Reed was refuted by me, concerning the key words in Quran EVERY TIME they brought up …
I have explain many time how …''Lam'' was used in 65/ 4 and NOT [ LAN ] and the effect of that on the meaning of '' yahidnna ''
Now, the fact that Reed and you did not come back with a refute, that means you have nothing to come back with, and in turn Reed and you were debunked.
Both of you know nothing of the Arabic language , and I do .. Reed has asked me to help him with his stumbles in Arabic and I agreed to help him … and there is nothing wrong with that .
written by Montegue , October 14, 2012
Muslims are simply the deluded dregs of all nations. Much more appalling to infidels is the willingness of their women, coming out in droves, to defend and exhort their own oppressors.
written by Reed Wilson. , October 14, 2012
Does it prove that? How simple!!
"Both of you know nothing of the Arabic language , and I do .. Reed has asked me to help him with his stumbles in Arabic and I agreed to help him … and there is nothing wrong with that."
I wonder if I ever said that. I use ready made translations of Quran done by Arabic knowing translators. Your Syrian Arabic confuses you.
written by Reed Wilson. , October 15, 2012
fineliving. You misinform "Reed the non Arab convert to Islam has posted all the words of '' DARB '' in compounded form IN QURAN and and I REFUTED him in each case , AND THEN HE DID NOT COME BACK WITH A REFUTE after that I took it as, he was throughly DEFEATED … he did not come back with any criticism of my criticism."
Please go back to those pages and threads. It is different that you have chosen to live in fools paradise. I some time dont feel necessary to answer some people according to following guidance:
خُذِ الْعَفْوَ وَأْمُرْ بِالْعُرْفِ وَأَعْرِضْ عَنِ الْجَاهِلِينَ
" Show forgiveness, enjoin equity, and avoid the ignorant." 7:199
You start beating drums of your victory.
written by abc , October 15, 2012
“Live with them on a footing of kindness and equity. If ye take a dislike to them it may be that ye dislike a thing, and Allah brings about through it a great deal of good.” (Quran: An-Nisaa 19)
You cannot take a verb in isolation to try and prove a point. That's not how it works. That is not how Islamic law is derived.
written by abc , October 15, 2012
“Live with them on a footing of kindness and equity. If ye take a dislike to them it may be that ye dislike a thing, and Allah brings about through it a great deal of good.” (Quran: An-Nisaa 19)
You cannot take a verb in isolation to try and prove a point. That's not how it works. That is not how Islamic law is derived.
written by fineliving56 , October 15, 2012
Islam watch is about the scrutiny of Islam and its prophet …. it is about bringing out the truth as it happened and bring out the lies biased Muslims made up .
I am participation in here to help bring out the *real and exact truth* about Muhammad/Quran.hadeeth,Sirah, …
The tradition way of doing it, is , for someone to bring out an issue ,in Islam and the other side have to criticize it back and forth …. and whatever issues left uncriticized, it will be considered the truth for now [ as Rami Rustom said ]
So for you, Reed to refuse to post back a refute to my charge, because ,as you say, you do not want to answer to ignorance , is IN IT SELF IS IGNORANCE .
I am surprised, of your post … didn't you know that by not coming back with a rebuttal after my rebuttal about the word '' idrubuhuna '' I am going to assume that you have nothing to say about it, because you agree with my rebuttal.
Why come here and post lies and dissipation … it is not right …Reed
I am not going to call you a fool like you called me .. I choose to refrain from name calling .
Go and check the link I provided and learn why '' idrubuhunna '' means '' beat them '' and not any of the compounded words that you have provided.
like…. Idrub Mathalan …or ... idrub fi al'ardi …. among others .
your refusal to agree about the REAL truth of that word, tells me that you do not CARE ABOUT THE TRUTH … instead …. You WANT to make up YOUR OWE truth about Quran and the word '' idrubuhuna '' so you can RATIONALIZE and say …Quran does not allows beating women.
Again … read my link from wikipila … and then come back and provide a refute to the link .
So when
written by Jye , October 15, 2012
4:34 says:
Men have charge of women because Allah has preferred the one above the other and because they spend their wealth on them. Right-acting women are obedient, safeguarding their husbands’ interests in their absence as Allah has guarded them. If there are women whose disobedience you fear, you may admonish them, refuse to sleep with them, and then beat them. But if they obey you, do not look for a way to punish them. Allah is All-High, Most Great.
I also have a Quran on PDF translated by Mohammed Pickthall. in his translation the the word beat is replaced with scourge.
scourge [skurj] Show IPA noun, verb, scourged, scourg·ing.
noun
1. a whip or lash, especially for the infliction of punishment or torture.
And I have seen the word chastise used in place of beat and scourge.
chas·tise [chas-tahyz, chas-tahyz] Show IPA
verb (used with object), chas·tised, chas·tis·ing.
1.to discipline, especially by corporal punishment.
I don't know what the Arabic word is, and since it has been translated into English, it's irrelevant. It's quite clear what verse 4:34 says; all synonyms of the same thing. It instructs a Muslim man to physically abuse his wife if he suspects her to be disobedient.
written by abc , October 15, 2012
Scenario 1.
Wife has cooked a dish you don't like. You have told her you don't like that dish before. Can I now grab my knuckledusters and chin her??
Scenario 2.
One morning she wakes up and declares herself an apostate???
Can I chin her now?
Come on experts i need some advice as to when I can use the right cross!!!
written by Jye , October 15, 2012
So, knock yourself out, your God has given you the go ahead.
written by Betty , October 15, 2012
written by abc , October 15, 2012
I think I've proved my point!
You jack asses know nothing!
written by Jye , October 15, 2012
Is your point that you live in delusion land where black means white and Islam really does mean peace?
If that's the case then you're welcome; I'm happy to prove your point that you're deluded.
written by Brown Superman , October 15, 2012
You must be quite sick to like spin on the koran. Are you a muslim or has your new found land fed you with pork, to like a spin on koran?
written by heapologiatoutimotheou , October 15, 2012
I think the fact that you have two wives is proof enough that your opinion is biased.
written by Malem , October 15, 2012
Heap, your statement is a heap, a heap of garbarge that is. You think you know what you are talking about but you are long lost lad. You are just another uniformed poster who reads a verse here and there and then tries to profess their expertise, haha, well you still sound ignorant of the subject at hand.
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 16, 2012
Unexplained assertion.
> You think you know what you are talking about but you are long lost lad.
Unexplained assertion.
> You are just another uniformed poster who reads a verse here and there and then tries to profess their expertise, haha, well you still sound ignorant of the subject at hand.
Unexplained assertion.
I just lost a few seconds of my life and I can't get it back. Thank you, Malem. (sarcasm)
Please, going forward explain your assertions using content. Let readers examine whether your assertion is right or not. We need content in order to do that.
written by Kaser , October 16, 2012
POSSIBLE REACTIONS:
1- Muslim husband A orders wives 2, 3, or 4 to cook from now on. Wife 1 spared preparing food - happy - but risks downgrading of her position in harem.
2- Muslim husband B refuses to eat, fixes his own meal, then "punishes" wife by not sleeping with her. Wife happy, no tedious joyless sex tonight (having been mutilated as a young girl, never knew pleasure anyway).
3- Salafi Muslim husband C in Islamic country, slaps her, throws food on the floor (and a tantrum). Repeats. Curses her "weak intelligence".
SCENARIO 2: Wife wakes up, declares apostasy:
POSSIBLE REACTIONS:
1- Muslim husband A orders wives 2, 3, and 4 to become wives 1, 2 and 3. New wife 4 (apostate) gives husband the finger, leaves household and gets a new life. Congrats! Husband worried this might have repercussions on other wives...
2- Muslim husband B can't believe it. Sees the light, decides to also leave Islam - but grows eyes behind his head, fearful of "repercussions"...
3- Salafi Muslim husband C slaps her some more, throws her on the floor (and a few kicks) - threatens death. Bad day in store for wife, whose already living a bad life anyho.
US WESTERN MALES would:
SCENARIO 1: Talk about it. Maybe I don't like the food, bu she does. Fair enough give and take. Next supper, I'll make the meal, that will show her !!!
SCENARIO 2: You're leaving the religion! It's about time !!!
Cheers,
written by Malem , October 16, 2012
Sound familiar kaser....it should its the majority of your posts.
written by Betty , October 16, 2012
written by fineliving56 , October 16, 2012
Humanity will be victorious over, Death over religions, Fear mongering and Rape children under the excuse of marriage …… among many more .
We will not stop
written by Kaser , October 16, 2012
Are you saying my post above does not depict reality (at least the non-humoristic portions).
Are you saying that a woman leaving Islam in Islamic countries will be able to do so without problems? Without repercussions?
Are you saying that a woman living in Islamic countries is never the subject of Religious-driven violence?
In my country, there is violence against women by low-life cowards. But these low-life cowards are not driven by religion.
Only Islam instructs husbands to beat their wives - whether or not you abide by this make no difference. Many Muslim men do.
Now please Malem, post another rant about how I don't understand anything... Please do.
written by Kaser , October 16, 2012
Malem is taking the stance that Islam is perfect and any criticism of it is automatically hateful Islam-bashing.
Critics (like me) are uneducated, unknowing, foaming-at-the-mouth idiots.
Note the constant avoidance of answering fundamental questions about the morality of scriptures.
Here goes again, for fun:
HEY MALEM, ANSWER THIS:
1- Do you beleive in being "ruthless to the unbelievers?"
2- Do you believe women are weak of intelligence and raligion?
3- Do you believe Christians are Vile and Jews are pigs?
Now any sentient human able to read will clearly see these teachings in the Quran.
Will Malem respond?
Wait for it.
written by Malem , October 16, 2012
Now your statement that “Critics (like me) are uneducated, unknowing, foaming-at-the-mouth idiots”, you labelled yourself, I have not used a description but I will let you call it like you see it.
written by Yibel , October 16, 2012
Bad news: The Taliban has vowed to murder her should she recover.
The cohesive core of Islam that continues to inspire its long history of violence is the Qur'an and the sayings (aHadith) and actions (Sunnah) of Muhammad. Islam’s doctrine of Shari’ah law is predominately dedicated to imposing control and exacting total obedience from Muslims. Islam is the problem! Ban Islam is the answer!
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 16, 2012
Here's some honest criticism.
Allah was fabricated by Mohamed, just like all Gods were fabricated by humans.
That idea conflicts with this idea:
Allah exists.
Why do you believe in the 2nd idea instead of the 1st idea?
(before you answer, please read my article titled _Is Allah Real?_)
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 16, 2012
Instead of making unexplained assertions, its better to quote the relevant text, point out the flaw, and explain why you think its a flaw.
If you don't do that, then why do you think your post is any smarter than Kaser's post?
> but do anyways to and disparage another persons religious choice
I think you are assuming that he does it to "disparage" *your* religious choice. What is your argument for that? How do you know he's not just criticizing Islam and criticizing the majority of its followers who are as immoral as Muslims were in the 7th century? Why do you think his criticism is directed at you?
If you didn't mean *your* religious choice, then what did you mean?
written by fineliving56 , October 16, 2012
'' not the old 72 virgins c__p ''
Then in that case, if we talk about the old '' un numbered'' virgins c__p, would that makes you happy ?
We know and you know … Quran has repeated time and time again that Muslim men will have many virgins [in plural ] with no number mentioned .
You harp on the # 72 of virgins … and by doing that , you duck answering why in the name Allah, would Allah, promise young virgins with big black eyes and big breasted, never been touched to Muslim men, while nothing in the fate of their wives ?
I know you will duck this question as you have done before … I only asked, for the reader to see the absurdity of Muslims when they harp on only the number 72 of virgins to deliberately avoid addressing the ** real gigantic problem with promising unlimited virgins ** to Muslim men .
72 or unlimited virgins … which is WORSE …ask your self ?
written by Brown Superman , October 16, 2012
Grow up little boy!
written by Brown Superman , October 16, 2012
Allah is a pimp running a brothel in heaven. The wives of muslim men are recycled (especially the hymen) into houris and put for use as if new. Thus " never been touched to muslim men". Also, Allah blows air into the points to inflate those at the chest.
written by Kafirwala , October 16, 2012
written by Betty , October 16, 2012
written by Betty , October 16, 2012
Starting in verse 54 of Surah 55 Ar-Raĥmān and going to the end of the Surah women/girls are mentioned many times.
Then in Surah 52 Aţ-Ţūr starting at verse 24 boys are mentioned, almost as if they have been saved from Hell by Allah to serve the men, any way they want.
Some answers I found Kaser, Qur'an Surah 48 Al-Fatĥ verse 59 "ruthless to the unbelievers"
Then in Surah 5 Al-Mā'idah verses 59-60 Cursed by Allah "Allah has cursed and with whom He became angry and made of them apes and pigs and slaves of Taghut" Taghut means rebel, as in we don't believe you.
written by Malem , October 16, 2012
Now as for Finelivings assertion that I am a moron, that is an interesting comment coming from a self confessed liar. Yes the person who lies to her own family and friends, have you no shame. That is so sad to live in such a dark corner. Yet you also try to use this terrible crime as a platform to further your hate speech, quite sad, very sad.
As for responding to Kaser, there was no direct question as I stated, should there be one, it might be answered. Peace
written by Malem , October 16, 2012
Finally instead of using the above article about the crime on a poor little girl for your own reward, why not speak out against the violent act in the article. Is there any reason you have not done so, you should be ashamed. Not once did you mention the young girl and what happened, it clearly shows your hatred has overshadowed your reasoning as a compasionate human. Very sad
written by Kaser , October 16, 2012
No answers from Malem, as usual.
You are right Kafirwala, there is Taqqiya present here!
written by Betty , October 16, 2012
written by Betty , October 16, 2012
written by Malem , October 16, 2012
Who are these houris you are fascinating about? Why are you asking about my erection? What kind of person are you? Is that lady like behavior? As for my wives, you can easily disparage them with anonymous posting, it only points out the kind of lady you are, and you have to live with that. So maybe you should look in the mirror and ask the same questions of yourself lass.
As for the translation site, I need not one. I can read the Koran verbatim dear, it is you that hath to depend on others to tell you what it means.
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 16, 2012
Ah you want to translate the Quran on your own. Thats good because many of the translations (from both pro-Islam and Islam-critical sites) are flawed. I have found many of those flaws myself.
Please see my post where I criticized some of your Islamic claims where I also cited some Quranic verses. Translate them yourself and we'll go back and forth criticizing each other's translations until we agree.
written by Kaser , October 16, 2012
That they are animals at best, I agree with you Malem. You leave out that they are motivated by Islamic teachings?
They resort to violence because their cause cannot be argued logically.
Again, this kind of attack on a young woman proves my point: Women will be the downfall of Islam. Attacking her is a true sign they also have identified the main threat against them.
The Oppressive bearded buffoons will fall.
Cheers,
written by Malem , October 17, 2012
written by Kaser , October 17, 2012
The Taliban interpret the Quranic verses in a violent manner that suits their goals and morals.
Like Boko Haram, Ansar Dine, Al Shabaab, ect...
The problem lies there Malem - that the Quranic verses are easily interpreted to incite intolerance which breeds violence.
I will not insult your intelligence by pasting said verses here, no more than you will insult mine by denying their existence in the Quran.
The Quranic verses are, by their complicated and convoluted nature, PROOF that humans are at their source.
This is clear, and more than enough for other humans to twist them to their own specific needs.
Would the Quran indeed be the manufacture of a "god" it wolud be different. Imagine the Quran being sent down in a blinding flash of light, simultaneously to all humans, in their own language, would leave no room for doubt. We would all be Muslims. You will admint, Malem, that a god having the power to create the universe could perform such a simple task no?
But this is not so. The Quran is the work of one man (and his followers thereafter) because at the time, they had the EXACT same NEEDS that Boko Haram, Ansar Dine, the Taliban and others have now to this day...
... namely, control over other humans - mainly women.
Cheers
written by Betty , October 17, 2012
The only copy/paste I used was the title of the Surahs, as my keyboard won't write arabic.
As for asking about your erection, the point was are YOUR wives going to be there to see you galloping around Jannah with your penis flopping here and there,or will they even get to heaven, having sex with houri after houri? Simple questions for a simple man.
Here in the US women are allowed to speak as they please, we aren't restricted by hung up males with masculinity and denial problems, so I can say anything I want.
And btw, you still haven't answered Kaser's questions, I did.
written by Malem , October 17, 2012
Stay Classy!
written by fineliving56 , October 17, 2012
The fact that, you, divide your time between two wives, back and forth, of course, with their knowledge, makes you the last man on this earth to have the nerve to talk about class …
Look how you bring up your wives subject in every other post PROUD and stomping on chest, while you should be hiding that fact when you are talking to non Muslims, because in their eyes, you are nothing but a bigamist and NOTHING ABOUT THAT, IS CLASSY.
Just stop talking about your wives … you look like a fool, Malam .. you are trying to look so democratic, while you give half a man to a whole women, and you do not allow your wives to do the same [ as Quran does not allow ]
You are really laying it thick .
written by Betty , October 17, 2012
written by Malem , October 17, 2012
written by Betty , October 17, 2012
written by Betty , October 17, 2012
written by Malem , October 17, 2012
FYI Betty the article was about a poor little girl and the animals whom attacked her, not satisfying your bizarre fantasies....
written by Betty , October 17, 2012
written by Archpagan , October 17, 2012
'Do you yourself plan to have an eternal erection there? Are you a real man? Are your wives going to be there to witness your repeated intercourse with houris? Or are they going to be someone else houris?
If those words appear vulgar/salacious for a lady to raise, then the faults rest with your scriptures not her. Why is there no demand from 'good' Muslims like you to ban parts of Scripture giving such vulgarity in the garb of religion/ spirituality? Answer like a virile man; don't behave like a newly-wed young bride.
written by Kaser , October 17, 2012
You will not get logical answers from Malem. He needs Islam whole and uncontested to continue his way of life.
He does not want to discuss Islam's many loopholes and obvious deficiencies. He knows about them.
His position is that Islam is perfect. If pushed in a corner, he will closes his eyes, blocks his ears and repeat "I am not listening... Ta-dee-dah... I am not listening..."
Him ever so slightly admitting that ANY portion of Islam is nonsence would open the floodgates. If a portion of Islam is flawed, then the rest is also flawed.
We would jump on this. He knows this.
Malem will never open a frank discussion about Islam because he does NOT want to, does not CARE to.
To maintain his two wives and his way of life, Islam must remain intact.
You will never get answers from him...
written by Kaser , October 17, 2012
He calls them "animals" - which they are also...
But he purposefully avoids the "Islamic" word because it suits his needs and belief system.
written by Duke Indian , October 17, 2012
What spirituality you expect in the Quran? my foot!......
written by fineliving56 , October 18, 2012
I have said the same thing to Malam, last year .
I have tried to make him understand from women's prospective and, as usual, he talked of what '' he THINKS '' his knows what in his first wife heart ! … what a fool?
When he replaced his first wife, with his second wife, Instead of letting her go to marry other man,[ or let her free ] like any DECENT MAN WOULD DO, he acts, typically, and keeps her to keep his boredom at bay or out of charity .
He did not know that when he told her, he is going to marry another , he broke something in her, it will never comeback … she might not tell him out of [ what ever ] but her love is nothing like it should be … so he is living a lie … I have no respect of such a man what so ever ..
How he likes it, if his first wife said … I want to marry a man, but I like to keep you on the side ?
Oh … No … it is not possible !… he would see RED, and he will kick her out and repeat to her [ Talaq … talaq … talaq ] and their marriage is over .
Betty ..
It is amazing how unfair Muslim women are treated in Islam…
When a woman is kicked out by her husband saying the three words to announce her divorce , she have to go to her families. If her husband want her back , SHE HAS TO MARRY ANOTHER MAN AND CONSUMMATE THE MARIGE and then divorce the second husband [ and we all know how easy to do that ] so she will be able, by Quran's law, to go back to him …
As a Teen … I asked, what is the wisdom behind this cruel treatment of women, the answer was more then cruel .. this was the answer :
'' so women will learn their lesson and not, ask for divorce every day and a lesson for the husbands too, so they will not throw out their wives , every day ..
So making the wife, marry a stranger for short time, will teach both Muslim husbands and wives the importance, in staying in the marriage and do not complain too much .
As you can see the Islamic marriage has nothing to do with feelings … it is about contracts, lessons, intercourse, children and control of women body.
I mean for a society to make a women marry a stranger for a day just to make her allegeable to marry her abuser [ first husband ] … has to be lowest, it can, reach .
written by Kaser , October 18, 2012
HEY MALEM - how about it? Would you agree to be married to a woman that already has a husband? Be one of two husbands? Or maybe one of four husbands?
What a joke!!!
written by Jye , October 18, 2012
:-D
written by The Real Indian , October 18, 2012
There's a saying that goes like
You may fool some people all the time(These are poor Islamic believers)
You may fool all the people some time (forceful conversion of conquered tribes and accept allah as the only god)
But You can never fool all the people all of the time(Do you see ex-muslims? Do you see the courage and faith of Indianistic religion to give up and accept Islam and surrender?)
As long as we strong men are alive... Evil Prophet's and all the Muslims dream of conquering all the lands and spreading Islam till everyone fears allah will always be a dream...
Islam Watch keep up the good work
written by abc , October 18, 2012
written by Jye , October 18, 2012
Great read. I enjoyed reading Malem getting his a$s whipped by two ladies.
:-D"
Makes a change from having your own arse whupped!
written by malem , October 19, 2012
As for why I would not respond to your questions, well that's easy, they're dumbass questions
Fineliving I realize your jealousy gets the best of you sometimes but my wives are very happy, and our love is strong as ever. When I return from hajj I hope to take the to the gulf for holiday. Its a beautiful time of year to go. I'd rather go to zabadani, but it appears that option will not be available until the animal bashar is pushed out
written by Betty , October 19, 2012
written by Kaser , October 19, 2012
Here goes again: Would you agree to be married to a woman that already has a husband? Be one of two husbands? Or maybe one of four husbands?
Quick, before you leave for Hajj!
written by This is Rami Rustom , October 19, 2012
Yes, asserting without explanation *is* easy. Its also a mistake. It happens to be a type of mistake that you keep repeating.
The hard part about discussion is supporting one's assertions with explanations. This requires thinking. And thinking is hard. Its also fun. You should try it. I think you'd like it.
So think about it. What is your explanation? Why do you think Betty's questions are not worthy of being answered?
written by non believer , October 19, 2012
written by Walter Sieruk , October 19, 2012
written by Jye , October 20, 2012
Makes a change from having your own arse whupped!
LOL! A bit hard to be "whupped" by you, abc, when more times than not you skulk away and stop replying. And when I say replying, I mean you never refuting any discussions, but instead posting ridiculous, little insults.
written by abc , October 20, 2012
Let me check my three books and find out!
Rotflmao
written by Jye , October 20, 2012












Just one in example of many you state "Women are polluting. Muslim men purify themselves following a casual contact with a woman." Yet you know that no where in the Koran does it state this. What you have done is put your own spin on it. What the Surah does is try and insure people are of clean mind, spirit and body before prayer.
Now if you focused on the story at hand versus going on your usual Islamophobic rant, you would have seen they arrested the thugs that committed this crime and they should be punsihed to the fullest extent of the law. NO WHERE In the Koran does it say women cannot go to school or learn, if that were true I would have a hard time explaining whay both my wives have advanced degrees and one even an adjunct professor teaching both women and men....
Nice try Jake, time to head back to the hate pool and stir another story up lad, Peace