• Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Losing Secular Turkey to Islamic Fundamentalism

E-mail Print PDF

Turkey is the much-touted outpost of secular-democracy in the Islamic world. It has been a common exercise for Islamic apologists to refer to Turkey as an example to Islam's compatibility with secular-democracy against those, who argue that Islam is incomptaible with democracy and in a cultural or civilizational clash with the rest of humanity. It's seems those apologists are headed to a dead-end.

Turkey today stands at the cross roads between fundamentalist Islam and the secular democracy introduced by Mustafa Ataturk in 1924 after he abolished the Caliphate of the Ottoman empire.

Turkey also stands at the geographical crossroads between Europe and the Eastern Islamic countries, and up to now Turkey has acted in a mediation capacity between Israel and countries like Iran. However President Recep Erdogan dreams of a revived Caliphate and the past glory of the Ottoman empire. Erdogan has been implementing a policy of stealth Jihad in Turkey, quietly replacing  pro-Western figures with fundamentalist leaders, especially in the military which has always been pro-Western. Since 1960, the military has intervened in Turkish politics three times in defence of secularism, which is enshrined as the bedrock of the nation's political system, laid out in the preamble of the republic's constitution. According to the Turkish Daily News, in 1995, Erdogan was quoted as having said: "Democracy is like a streetcar. You ride it until you arrive at your destination and then you get off." [2] From his body language and recent actions, Erdogan is signalling to the world that Turkey is ready to disembark from the streetcar called Democracy.

In this article, we will examine the policy changes and government statements that underline a realignment of Turkey to Islamic countries like Syria, Lebanon and Iran, and the implications both for Israel and the West.

Turkey’s changing direction


Formally, Ankara remains committed to joining the EU, but the idea of joining has lost much of its appeal after years of rejection and additional European demands to repeatedly prove that it is worthy.

Indeed, Germany and France remain adamantly opposed to Turkey's entrance to the EU. At a recent joint television appearance in Berlin, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Nicolas Sarkozy made clear their opposition to Turkish EU membership.

Turkey, however, has made efforts to develop better relations with Arab states and such other countries as Russia, Syria and Iraq – and even Armenia, a traditional foe.

Consider now a poem written by Recep Erdogan which reflects his true feelings:

“The mosques are our barracks, the domes our helmets, the minarets our bayonetes and the believers are our soldiers. This Holy army guards my religion. Almighty, our journey is our destiny, the end is martyrdom”. [2]

Hardly the words of a secularist!

Arab countries which never were enamoured with the post-Ottoman leadership now look with admiration to what is referred to as the "Turkish model."

In addition, Turkey is looking to re-establish its historical influence in the Turkic countries of Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. In this Central Asian region, Turkey sees itself in a peacekeeping role where it either ruled or dominated for centuries.

The apparent change in course for Turkish foreign policy may be due partially to a new generation of advisers surrounding Erodogan. Turkey's new foreign minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, is one such influential adviser who has outlined what he calls a "multidimensional policy" contrary to what has been practiced. [2]

Ahmet Davutoglu

His predecessors have focused entirely on the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, Europe and the U.S.
Observers point out that Davutoglu's origins are from what is called Central Anatolia which encompasses most of modern Turkey, the Caucasus and Iran. He is said to be heavily influenced by Islamic thought and has no hesitation in embracing Turkey's past Ottoman empire which included countries over which Turkey seeks to regain influence. Given his eastern education, Davutoglu believes that Turkey should not be so committed only to a western orientation.

Davutoglu readily approaches countries deemed to be bad guys in the eyes of the U.S. – Syria and Iran, and such groups as Hezbollah and Hamas which the U.S. has labeled as terrorist groups.

The Turkey Israel alliance

Turkey, a secular country ruled by an Islamic-oriented party, had long been Israel's best friend in the Muslim world. But ties have cooled sharply over Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's sharp criticism of Israel's winter war in the Gaza Strip.Tukey-Israel

News flash: Turkey bans Israel from military exercises.
The Israeli military said the Oct. 12-23 drill was delayed indefinitely "because of Turkey's decision to change the list of participating countries, thus excluding Israel."

The exercise was to have been the sixth annual manoeuvre of its kind. The military said it was to have included U.S., Italian and NATO forces.

Israeli defence officials said Ankara cancelled the drill after the U.S. pulled out over the Turkish decision to blackball Israel. [3]

Turkey initiates military exercises with Syria

NATO member Turkey and Syria hold first joint military exercise [April 26, 2009]

Turkey and SyriaThe joint Turkish-Syrian tank and armoured infantry exercise backed by air power begins across the Turkish-Syrian border Monday, April 27, and lasts three days.

DEBKAfile's military sources stress that it is the first joint military manoeuvre any NATO member, including Turkey, has ever carried out with Syria. It appears to have received a nod from the Obama administration and another first: Never before has an important NATO power staged a joint exercise with any Arab army.

Ankara's decision to launch the drill on the day Israeli commemorates its war dead - in league with Iran's leading ally - is a measure of how far Turkey's longstanding strategic pact with the Jewish state has fallen by the wayside of recent changes.

Washington's approval underscores its new policy of boosting the strength of the Syrian army as partner in a strong a three-way military coalition with Turkey and Lebanon. [4]

In Summary

Recep Erdogan and his Islamist AKP party have been moving closer to a fundamentalist position by purging the Military of its secular leaders and stacking the courts with Islamists. The second  fall of Constantinople will be peaceful, and is almost complete.

In addition, Turkey is no more an ally of Israel and has broken Military ties as well as forging new Military alliances with Israel’s enemies, including Syria, Lebanon, Iran, Hamas and Hizbollah.

Turkey has the second largest Military in NATO and has been supplied advanced weaponry by both the USA and Israel. A military alliance with these Islamist countries, which could also include Pakistan soon is an enormous threat to World peace.

Lest We Forget – the Armenian genocide

Many westerners today are intrigued by Turkey and its culture. However we must never forget what this nation is capable of. Over 1.5 million Armenians were killed in what can only be called a genocide through the deliberate actions of the Turkish government. Even today, Turkey denies this genocide ever took place!


1. Shoebat Walid.  God’s War on Terror; Islam, Prophecy and the Bible
Turkey ‘s street car called democracy
Turkey bans Israel from war games
Turkey holds joint Military exercises with Syria

Comments (7)Add Comment
written by Louie , November 11, 2009
hmmm... well you definitely got your trend towards Islamism. The more observant a Muslim is, the more violent he is, and the less he can be criticized. It's a political and philosophical position just waiting for the opportunistic to exploit it.

Here's hoping Turkey has enough experience with Muslims that they'll know how to treat this situation.

You know who had a secular mideast country without a viable insurgency... it was Sadaam Hussein of Iraq. It was really a mistake to hang him... now we need more of him. The Al Quaida types hated Sadaam because he was so secular, but they couldn't move against him for fear that the Shia would arise and join Iran.

It can be difficult... no doubt, to reign over competing societies, any of whom would gladly die just for the honor of killing someone... But mess with Sadaam and he would destroy your whole village.

It seemed cruel and oppressive when Bush was screwing things up... but seriously... if you deal with an Islamic insurgency in any other way, you're just feeding it. If Turkey starts covert executions and wholesale destruction of the small insurgency they have now... all will be better in Turkey than it is in Britainstan.

why is it that the civilised world never learnt from the past
written by Clement , November 11, 2009
unequal yoke with Islamic nation both in EU and UN is a risky business. Islam is for world conquest with their depraved belief system call the "the religion of peace" they will do anything to deceive in order to conquer.My worried is that the west are still blind to the evil of Islam.They world is yet to come to terms that Islam is evil and should not be allowed to coexist with the civilised world of humanity. The nations of the world should come together and device a none combatant way to rid the world of Islam and set the captive of Islam free.
written by Machmoed elchalid , November 12, 2009
Well, in this particular case Turkey was wright and Isreal lied in an debate with Erdogun and then Erdogun left because of the cruelty's israel militaryforce did in those days. Europe has condamned these crimes as well as a lot of countries and ofcourse the US did not.

furthermore: Turkey is still not allowed to the european union and Europe said this will not be the case in the next 5 years or more. From that time Turkey is looking the other side to cooperate with the eastern civilizations instead of the west. Maybe this has turned them to islamic ideology, but ofcourse this is just a speculation.
Turkey must realign with the Ummah.
written by saladin , November 12, 2009
It is in Turkey`s long term interest to realign with the eastern powers.
The Arab world,Iran,Russia and China are the rising regional and world powers,Amerika and it`s European clients are all washed up.They have nothing to offer humanity except continued oppression and exploitation,whatever can be made in the "west",can be made better and cheaper in the East.

The Islamic countries will,when the time is right, use their weapons of economic destruction(oil/gas/$ reserves),and hold the Islamic bomb(Pakistan/Iran and..?)in their quiver of escalation.

In any nuclear exchange, the east is far better positioned to survive than the "west",with their stagnant populations and unsustainable lifestyles.
written by Machmoed , November 13, 2009
I really hope that people will see the need of peace for the sake of humanity. If I where all powerfull wich I'm not, then i would destroy all the mass destruction weapons and i would secularize the whole world. Everybody could believe whatever he/she want to believe within the borders of the law. If then someone want to pray to his/her God who am I to deny this since there a billions op people who find power to move on with their lives. But The ideology that you have to convert people to some kind of religion is bad news and not godly. Every person if he is religious still believes in different Gods. God to me is different than to you and so is Allah different even for muslims....it is very personal and to submiss others to what you believe is rediculous.
written by NSC London , November 14, 2009
It is in Turkey`s long term interest to realign with the eastern powers.

I completely agree. They should also stop begging, hat in hand, to join the EU. Gee, Europe is so "stagnant" Turkey has been pleading for admission since 1988.

The Arab world,Iran,Russia and China are the rising regional and
world powers,

How is the Arab world "rising?" Last I checked while India was exploring the moon, the "Arab World" was debating about whether or not women should have the right to wear trousers. Yeah, you're so advanced.

Amerika and it`s European clients are all washed up.They have nothing to offer humanity except continued oppression and exploitation,whatever can be made in the "west",can be made better and cheaper in the East.

What exactly does Islam have to offer anyone? Female genital mutilation? Child brides? You people can't even manage your own pathetic excuses for nations, it's pretty amusing that you believe you can manage ours. In short, as they say in the US, "talk to me when you've done something, boy."

The Islamic countries will,when the time is right, use their weapons of economic destruction(oil/gas/$ reserves)

Oh really? The US now controls the second largest oil reserve on earth. Thanks Saddam!

In any nuclear exchange, the east is far better positioned to survive than the "west",with their stagnant populations and unsustainable lifestyles.

Praise Allah you are a stupid man! Anyone who advocates nuclear exchange is a complete idiot, not that I'm stating anything about you we didn't already know.
written by NSC London , November 20, 2009
You know, one thing about Aladdin you gotta admire is that the boy knows when he's been had.

Way to bow out gracefully Salad Dressing, no one here thinks you are a pathetic, weak coward who brings shame upon your family.

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comments.


About the book || Reviews by: Steven Simpson | Abul Kasem | Prof Sami Alrabaa | Ibn Kammuna


'Islamic Jihad' in Bangla
Aasma Riaz: "Thank you so much for your book "Islamic Jihad" and showing me the "Big Picture". For 7-8 days, I was glued to your book, absorbing so much information that I did not know existed. You have crisply covered so much in your book and quoted historical references extensively. I am just overwhelmed with different emotions after reading your book..., a priceless tome."

Editor: M A Khan | Site design: Dan Zaremba
Founded on 20 November 2005


* Aisha and Muhammad, the movie:

Bill Maher: 'Islam is the worst'
• Bill Maher on "72 Virgins"