www.islam-watch.org

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Why Islam Prohibits the Propagation of Other Religions in Muslim Countries?

E-mail Print PDF

Why Islam prohibits other religions to be propagated in Muslim world? This question always been pinching many Muslims, including self-claimed scholars of Islam, such as Dr. Zakir Naik, Jamal Badawi and so on. And they try their best to give a proper answer, but interestingly, their explanation is so poor and childish that they don’t know what they are explaining.

It is true that, in history, we find evidence that religions, either monotheism or polytheism, had shown varying degrees of fanaticism in one way or another. For example, if someone would say anything against God or Goddess, they would be persecuted by their priests and rulers. But those are bygone days, the days were of ignorance. Today everywhere in Europe and America, this kind of barbarism is condemned in Christianity, Judaism, or any other religion, except Islam.

Islam is a unique and the only religion, not only prohibits other religions to be propagated in Muslim territories, but also allows killing of those, who try to convert Muslims to their own faith and those, who leave Islam.

It is said that Saudi Arabia is the only Muslim country, where propagation of other religions is prohibited, but the truth is otherwise; not only Saudi Arabia but also Pakistan, Iran, Iraq, Sudan, along with all Muslim countries, even proverbially moderate Malaysia, prohibit the propagation of religions other than Islam.

Here we will see a video of Mr. Zakir Naik (an Indian Muslim scholar), the self-proclaimed champion of debates, who has, interestingly, been banned by his own Muslims from talking rubbish and nonsense in his speeches. Fatwas have been levied on him and he has been attributed as a Kaffir and non-Muslim. In this video, a questioner asked him about the propagation of other religions in Muslim countries and how he stupidly answer the question that 2 + 2 = 4, that is Islam and other religions are false because they teach 2 + 2 = 5 or 3 or 6 etc…

All religious people will always defend their religion. A Christian thinks his religion is the best, others are wrong; Jews will also think in the same way, and it is natural. But the answer of Zakir Naik is so hilarious that really made me astonished and shocked; I couldn’t expect such a stupid answer from a child.

The Situation in Pakistan

As a Pakistani born Ex-Muslim, I can say with certainty that I have seen Hindus not more than 3 or 4 in 36 years. I might have met just 10-15 Christians in my life. I never met a Jew in Pakistan.

On Pakistani passports, it is categorically mentioned that this passport is valid anywhere in the world but Israel. It means that a Pakistani can’t go to Israel directly from Pakistan. The same is true for almost all Muslim countries. Islamic hatred of the Jewish state is that high.

97% of the population in Pakistan are Muslims that include Shia, Wahabis, Ahle Hadees, and such sects. Qadianis were considered a Muslim community but Supreme Court of Pakistan declared them non-Muslims in 1973 and were thus expelled from Islam. Interesting point is that Qadianis still call themselves Muslim and reject the Supreme Court ruling. If we put Qadianis into the Muslim list, the Pakistani population will be 99% Muslim.

In Pakistan, Muslims severely condemn a Muslim if found reading the Bible. Hence, a big mass of Muslim community don’t know at all about Hinduism, Christianity, Judaism and Buddhism. The sorry thing is that they even don’t understand the Arabic language, said to be their pious language.

Causes of Spreading of Islam

One may, quite reasonably, wonder: why Islam is still alive even after knowing the truth about its founder and his followers and successors, who were very bad people and wrong-doers, and adopted evil way of life. Their best weapon to keep Islam alive and well was kill anyone who comes in their way and not give a single chance, to others, even to think logically and wisely, but to follow as they were told.

If a religion prohibits other religions in their territories, it would definitely overcome any adversity and maintain and propagate it followers. Harassment or threat of killing of apostates would ensure that nobody can leave the religion.

On the other hand, polygamy, which snatched the rights of women away helped produce Muslim children in large number, thereby, rapidly increasing the Muslim population.

Islam would have died even long ago, if the intrusion of other religions in Islamic territories was possible. It would have enabled Muslims -- who interacted with Christians, Jews, Hindus, Buddhists and so on -- would think wisely and their aptitude towards Islam would be quite different from what it is today.

Conclusion

We have come to know that Islam prohibits the propagation of other religions in Muslim countries. For that reason, non-Muslims are harassed if they propagate their religions in Islamic countries;  they might even get killed.

When this is the case: why non-Muslim countries, especially the Western World, allow propagation of Islam in their countries? It is only logical that non-Muslim countries should also prohibit the preaching of Islam, so long Muslim countries maintain a ban on the propagation of other religions. If non-Muslim countries, like the Muslim one, prohibit the promulgation of Islam, I can say with certainty that Islam, an incendiary religion, will be eliminated from the face of earth sooner.

Comments (56)Add Comment
0
Islam wont survive if other religions are given a chance
written by logic , December 23, 2010
Islam is a failed religion ..its a religion of hopelessness ....a religion based on fear,persecution,blood and bigotry .............have a look at the islamic nations .......which are basically nations whose people were devoured by the SWORD of ISLAM ...............such hopeless religions which justify their authenticity on numbers ..............will never allow other religions .....to preach ...their people ...........never ever .............I pity pity muslims who have enslaved themselves to such a death-brigade .
0
...
written by Reed Wilson. , December 23, 2010
The author hails from a so called Muslim country Pakistan about which Pope John Paul XIV observed that Pakistan was most fertile land for Christianity. It is a fact also.

Jews and Hindus dont propagate their religion.
0
...
written by Reed Wilson. , December 23, 2010
Mr. Khan. You write "As a Pakistani born Ex-Muslim, I can say with certainty that I have seen Hindus not more than 3 or 4 in 36 years. I might have met just 10-15 Christians in my life. I never met a Jew in Pakistan". I give below some information for you:

Hindus In Pakistan
Hindus constitute about 2.5 per cent, or 26 lakh, of Pakistan's population.

Though sprinkled all over Pakistan, 95 per cent of Hindus are in Sindh.

Only Tharparkar district in Sindh has Hindus in majority: 51 per cent.

Other districts with sizeable population: Mirpur Khas (41 per cent), Sanghar (35 per cent), Umerkot (43 per cent)

Nearly 82 per cent of Pakistani Hindus are lower caste, most of them farm labourers

Cities with some Hindu population: Karachi, Hyderabad, Jacobabad, Lahore, Peshawar and Quetta.

In Tharparkar, Hindus own land. Krishen Bheel, Gyan Chand and Ramesh Lal are the Hindus in the Pakistan National Assembly.

Christianity in Pakistan
Christians are the second largest religious minority community in Pakistan after Hindus. The total number of Christians in Pakistan is approximately 2,800,000 in 2008, or 1.6% of the population. Of these, approximately half are Roman Catholic and half Protestant.[1] There also is a sizeable minority of the New Apostolic Church.
0
Hindus in Pakistan
written by logic , December 23, 2010
A MOSLIM writes about Hindus in Pakistan ....a MOSLIM writes about christians in Pakistan ......................oh lord what a shame wat a shame ...........how such people even exist and call themselves your being .......oh lord please forgive these "THINGS" who sometimes confuse themselves as "HUMANS" ...like ...MUHAMMED confused himself as a prophet !!! ..........in simple man terms i mean ................no muslim has any authority ....to speak about ethics ...after ..fuc**** ...HUMANITY
0
...
written by Reed Wilson. , December 23, 2010
To logic. I can understand your feelings. Every humanist should think in these terms.
0
To Muhammad A. Khan & Reed Wilson
written by Archpagan , December 23, 2010
I am not astonished at Muhammad A. Khan's assertion that he has seen just 3 or 4 Hindus in his 36 years of stay in Pakistan. In the 1980's, once I came across a news-line in an English daily which read- '50% of the Hindus of Lahore is killed'. On going through the news-matter, I came to learn that there were just 2 Hindus in Lahore and one of them has been killed over a land dispute.

Tharparkar district had Hindu majority in 1947, but I don't think it is still so. Khulna district, constituting South-Western part of Bangladesh bordering India, too, had Hindu majority in 1947. But, now Hindus are less than 25% of the district's population.
0
from above
written by Machmoed , December 23, 2010
Muhammad A. Khan didn't say they do not existin Pakistan, only that he had seen a few of them. It wasn't a question also.

Why can't a pakistani muslim write about ethnics of his country. History is full of these examples. It's about what's written and what references are used. Certainley not the messenger i hope. For example, without the hadith and sira's we even couldn't say anything bad about the assumed messenger. This is the reason that Reed insists on denying Hadith.

Who does have the authority, the west, the east, the south or north. To my estimation no one should have. It's this authority that enslaved people in the name of a God, because according to their faith, God granted them that authority. Favouring a group of people to be the chosen one is hilarious and rediculous at the same time. Judaism started it and the lie kept going and then after others the arabs did the trick again and fooled the world again. They all used the same concept...god as a monarch/king/ruler like the rulers/kings/sultans or whatever on earth.
0
Poor Pakistan!
written by The Great Buana , December 23, 2010
Does Pakistan has any choice? If the people of Pakistan once leave islam, Pakistan as a political entity is over. So what can the people of Pakistan do? If they leave islam, there will be no order and no independent state any more. But is there anything else than islam that could provide unity and identity to the pashtuns, belutschis and all the other hundereds of ethnicities? The pakistani citizenship looks like a prison to me. Is there anybody in the world who would apply for it? I think even poor muslims from India prefer to live there - and not in the muslim home and model country. But why are there so many islamic failed states in the world? The reasons seems very pbvious to me: Muslims can never accept the rule of a modern state and its laws. They only recognize islam and this means in fact nothing but chaos and backwardness!
0
True face of Islam
written by lw1 , December 23, 2010
23/12/2010
Trio guilty of Sydney attack plot. -- Three men have been found guilty of plotting a suicide attack on an army base in Australian city of Sydney. A Melbourne court found them guilty of conspiring to commit a terrorist act. Two other defendents were acquitted. The five men, all Australian citizens of Somali or Lebanese origin, were arrested in Melbourne in August 2009. They were accused of targeting Sydney's Holsworthy military base. Police said the attack would have been the worst in Australian history.
Man fined for French flag insult. -- A court in South France has fined an Algerian man 750 euros (£637. $984) for insulting the national flag -- the first penalty under a new decree. Abderrahamane Saidi ,26, was at a local government office on Tuesday when he grabbed a flag and snapped the pole in two during a row with a clerk. A July decree made insulting the tricolor an offence punishable by a fine of upto 1500 euros. The rule was triggered by a photo of a man wiping his bottom with a flag.
Deportation petition handed over. --- A petition has been presented at Whitehall in support of a teenager from Pakistan now living in Carmarthenshire, Wales, in a final bid to avoid deportation. Ahmer Rana is due to be sent back to Pakistan after he turns 18 on Christmas Day. He was smuggled into the UK aged 14 after family fears he may be killed in a feud involving enemies of his father. The UK Border Agency has said there is no reason to offer him protection and he would definitely be deported.
Islam creates hell on earth. Even after moving away from that hell, Muslims want to create hell in countries they have settled in, legally or illegally.
0
non-muslim countries
written by Rationalist , December 23, 2010
In non-islamic coutries Muslims interact with Christians, Jews, Hindus, Buddhists, and even atheists. In spite of that very few muslims convert to other religions. In such countries Muslims cannot kill fellow muslims for converting to other religions. I feel it takes lot of conviction for a born-Muslim to give up Islam.
0
Dumber Than I Thought
written by DEWDDS , December 23, 2010
Everytime I see a video from this cretin Naik, I am surprised yet again at how he manages to sound more stupid than the last one. It's no surpise this half-wit quit medicine to become a traveling side show for his ridiculous religion.
0
Light and darkness
written by non believer , December 24, 2010
If darkness has to be protected, light must not be allowed. That is the principle of Islam. If it is open to logic (light) it will die. It was a religion made to fulfill the lust and greed of one individual who was cunning enough to don the mantle of a prophet and lived among gullible and crooked individuals who saw an opportunity to be part of a kill, rape and loot regime.
0
...
written by vbv , December 24, 2010
Muslim countries do not allow propogation of other religions and non-religions , because islam is inherently a failed criminal cult that can sustain itself only by keeping its adherents in line line dumb sheep by coercion , physical annihilation of anyone who even dares to question any of the stupidities (like the one in the video posted alongwith this article) that are inherent in this cult ,its irrationalities and superstitions that keep its followers always stupified and bereft of their natural intelligence. You have Zakir Naik who talks rubbish all the time waxing eloquent of the 'greatness and truth' in islam while he still wears the badge of an upper caste hindu for not having shed the surname "Naik" from his other arabic name Zakir. "Naiks" are upper caste hindus in the West coastal region or the Konkan coast of India stretching from Karnataka,Goa right upto Maharashtra. This man Zakir is still fond of his "kaffir" ancestry. This is doublespeak and hypocrisy - while on the one hand this Zakir Naik licks the shit of Arabia ,while on the other hand he will not let go of the hindu title "Naik". This is very common with muslims in India,Pakistan and Bagladesh where you can find surnames such as Naik,Coudhury, Bhatt,Rao,etc after their arabian or persian names. So much for these arab arse-lickers.
0
vbv
written by Rationalist , December 24, 2010
Naik means leader. Naiks were the warrior-class Hindus in the western belt of India. Zakir Nalayak's forefathers must have been forced to accept Islam. Instead of defending his forefather's religion, this arab arse-licker is licking the boot of Arabs. What a tragedy!
0
Reciprocity
written by Demsci , December 24, 2010
So we see 2 sorts of Nations, Democratic and Islamic ones, (among others of course). And in the Islamic ones, there is huge propaganda for Islam and much censorship and prohibition of proselytising for other religions, even of possession of bibles in many cases.

While in the Democratic Nations there now are many Muslims, whose percentage of the population is still growing, that are treated completely equal, who have almost total freedom of religion/ worship and speech, so also proselytising. There is not much "speakcrime" in the law and custom, as there is in the Islamic countries.

If we look at the world divided into followers of faith or other life-conviction, then ever since large numbers of Muslims migrated to Democratic Nations, this situation creates a huge unbalance worldwide, heavily in favor of the Muslims and to the disadvantage of Christians, Jews and Hindus.

Now the question must be put to Muslims living in Democratic Nations to who they are really primarily loyal to; the Islamic Ummah, and its laws or the Democratic Nations and their laws. And in part of the laws and interests these two very much are in conflict. And now that more and more citizens of Democratic Nations get more and more knowledge about both Islam and Democracy in all its aspects Muslims must realize they can't deny this credibly much longer, as they now try.

If they choose the former; then that opens the door to let them be treated like their fellow-Ummah-members treat the brothers and sisters of the Christians and Hindus in Democratic Nations are treated in Islamic Nations. Like the Christians saying that Muslims teach that 2+2=22 and therefore Islamic teaching and proselytising is not allowed in the public space, only in the private space.

If they choose the latter, then they have much to do; they have to provide proof by reforming Islam until it totally fits under Democracy, they have to declare to be totally loyal to Democratic Nations and its laws and completely hostile to enemies of those.
0
to Demsci
written by Mohammad.A.Khan , December 24, 2010
I agree with you. Well said

have a good day
Mohammad.A.khan
0
Good Commentaries
written by William East , December 24, 2010
I'm continously astonished at the intolerance of Islam. Islam denies freedom of choice. God does not do not deny freedom of choice. God created mankind with free will, we are allowed to choose. But Islam usurps God authoirty by judging and then murdering or punishing when and where it is able to function unabated. How can a single muslim be accounted as being sincere when a sword hangs over their neck? Justified intolerance breeds insincerity. Islam can only present itself as the truth when every follower is allowed to live as before God as an individual and not through an enforced system of religious law. Islam proves itself to be false by denying free will decisions on a religious level.
0
Christen nation reward s Muslim countries with billlions......
written by dead or alive , December 24, 2010
We here in the states know that more money goes to Muslim countries that have less Christians.Some poorer Muslim countries tax the hell out of their minority,which tax goes to their own demise though jihad.Here in the states jihad is raised through the guise of 501c3 state run church and charities.Its very importune for USA to be a Christian nation.
0
...
written by Reed Wilson. , December 25, 2010
To Machmoed. You write “Muhammad A. Khan didn't say they do not exist in Pakistan, only that he had seen a few of them. It wasn't a question also”.

Yes Mach. he did not say that nor did I question him. It was not a question either. The question was “Why Islam Prohibits the Propagation of Other Religions in Muslim Countries? I looked for the reason in his article. It must be there but it was shrouded.
0
To Machmoed.
written by Reed Wilson. , December 25, 2010
You write “Why can't a pakistani muslim write about ethnics of his country”. I don’t know why people are not writing about ethics of respective countries. May be because ‘history was full of such examples’.

You write “For example, without the hadith and sira's we even couldn't say anything bad about the assumed messenger. This is the reason that Reed insists on denying Hadith”.

Now you have hadith and sira and you can write everything about the assumed messenger. Only Reed Wilson is denying that. This does nt matter much.

You write “Who does have the authority, the west, the east, the south or north? To my estimation no one should have. It's this authority that enslaved people in the name of a God, because according to their faith, God granted them that authority. Favoring a group of people to be the chosen one is hilarious and ridiculous at the same time. Judaism started it and the lie kept going and then after others the Arabs did the trick again and fooled the world again. They all used the same concept...god as a monarch/king/ruler like the rulers/kings/sultans or whatever on earth”.

You are not sparing Jews even. My estimation is that we all have the authority or capability of doing good or evil by the God almighty. He has informed what is good and what is bad. He has also warned that whoever will do evil, he will do so at his own risk and cost. God has also given us the concept of punishment and reward.



0
...
written by Manikant , December 25, 2010
Logic of Zakir Naik

Example 1)

2+2 = 4, So Islam is true.

This logic is like this:

One day Zakir Naik was teaching about his religion to a few students.

Zakir Naik: ” If the train is running at a speed of 70 km/hour , then what is my age” ?

Student: ” Sir, your age is 44 years.”

Zakir Naik : (proudly gave a back pat to the student and said) : ” Very good. How did you arrive at my correct age ” ?

Student: ” Sir, I have a brother at home who is half mad and he is 22 years old. “



2) Circular logic:
Islam is good because the Quran says so.
The Quran is the word of God because Mohammed says so.
Mohammed is great because Islam says so.

3) Logic of Zakir Naik:
An apostate (of Islam) has to be killed – ( he compares with an army desrter) just like a person leaving the army is killed – meaning he is a traitor.
Religion = self improvement
Army = defends borders.
The example Zakir Naik has used is wrong. The army deserters are not killed. They are subject to the laws of the country.
Rather, he should have given the example of a criminal wanting to leave the underworld mafia. The underworld mafia does not allow to leave them as they fear that their secrets will be spilled. They just kill the person who wants to leave crime.
0
to Reed Wilson
written by Mohammad.A.Khan , December 25, 2010
Mr. Wilson, what kind of medicine you take for you mental illness?

have a nice christmas

Mohammad.A.Khan
0
Merry Christmas
written by duh_swami , December 25, 2010
Merry Christmas to those who celebrate it...For those who don't, sorry you missed out on all the fun...
0
Reed
written by Machmoed , December 25, 2010
You are not sparing Jews even. My estimation is that we all have the authority or capability of doing good or evil by the God almighty.

Authoroty wasn't about doing good or bad, it's about judgement. Who has the authoroty to judge?
The post wasn't directed to you either.
0
To all readers of Islam Watch.
written by Healer_999 , December 25, 2010

Happy Christmas.
0
To. Mr. Mohammad.A.Khan.
written by Reed Wilson. , December 25, 2010
Mr. Khan. you write “Mr. Wilson, what kind of medicine you take for you mental illness? Have a nice Christmas”.

Thanks for the greetings on Christmas. I wish all the visitors of Islam-watch “Merry Charismas” and “Happy New Year” in its wake.

What kind of medicine? It is a very technical question its answer requires expertise to understand. By no means I consider you a layman in this field. I even don’t know if you were an expert. I will tell you. If you tell me if you have some qualification in pharmacology or Pharmacognosy it will help me replying you in more detail.

My mental illness? I will not plead I am normal on the basis that nothing has been diagnosed so far. Once ‘fixed delusion’ was pointed out here. It was not found. I am old timer; Crossing seventy-five next birthday. I do take some supplements and stimulants like Pepsi, tea, coffee, beer, acetaminophen and Lectopam; Last two being mild tranquilizers.

There are still some societies where mental maladies are subject of ridiculing, insulting and mockery and the patients do not receive any sympathies. This trend is fading with the advancement of civilization.


0
wonderful wishes
written by fineliving56 , December 25, 2010
Happy Christmas and holidays to all …. for me around this time not celebrating Islamic holidays does not mean having to quite cooking and creating the most delicious food in dinner parties for family and friends …the warm feelings it creates is so rewording ….celebrating life it is what is all about …I which all readers happy times .
0
Concepts
written by Garden Variety Troll , December 25, 2010
... My estimation is that we all have the authority or capability of doing good or evil by the God almighty.
It's called free will.
0
To Reed Wilson
written by Archpagan , December 26, 2010
You wrote-' My estimation is that we all have the authority or capability of doing good or evil by the God almighty. He has informed what is good and what is bad. He has also warned that whoever will do evil, he will do so at his own risk and cost. God has also given us the concept of punishment and reward.'

Perhaps Mr. Khan wanted to ask what smoke you are taking now. Anyway, you must agree that you are in bad company.
0
Reed
written by fineliving56 , December 26, 2010
You Take coffee ,tea,and BEER….I thought you are a devout muslim who never stray from the never ending God's almighty rules and regulation …Alcohol is forbidden ….I hope you do not end up in jehannam ….all your hard work will go to waste here in these web sites.
0
To fineliving 56 and Archpagan.
written by Reed Wilson. , December 26, 2010
To fineliving56. You write "You Take coffee ,tea,and BEER….I thought you are a devout muslim who never stray from the never ending God's almighty rules and regulation …Alcohol is forbidden ….I hope you do not end up in jehannam ….all your hard work will go to waste here in these web sites".

Thank you for our concern. I Try to live according to God's will. Alcohol is not forbidden in Quran. You can even, take spirits to the level they do not intoxicate you.

Archpagan. You write "Perhaps Mr. Khan wanted to ask what smoke you are taking now. Anyway, you must agree that you are in bad company".

Perhaps. May be you want to know. I will not tell you. Bad company! I dont think so.



0
to Reed Wilson
written by Mohammad.A.Khan , December 26, 2010
Hi Reed, ever since, I am corresponding with you on this website, I have come to a conclusion that to understand up and down of any religion especially Islam is beyond your reach. Thus, to put this view before me, I have decided to leave talking on Islam or religion with you, but rather talk with you on politics and current affairs, perhaps your knowledge would be greater in this specific field.

As long as my question about the medicine for your mental illness goes, actually I wanted to know the name of medicine that I could avoid for myself. Believe me, I didn't ask this question to redicule you, but, for myself awareness, anyways...

So lets come to the politics topics. In which country do you live? who is your president and what are the political circumstances in your country?

Mohammad.A.Khan
0
...
written by duh_swami , December 26, 2010
I Try to live according to God's will. Alcohol is not forbidden in Quran.

Neither is shooting heroin into your veins...Allah says nothing about that, or taking LSD, or smoking dope... So if Allah does not prohibit these things in Quran, can we can assume Allah approves of them?
0
Zakir Naik's Rant
written by Arvind Raje , December 26, 2010
Ayesha Ahmed had once described the techniques of the Islamists to 'defeat' their opponents in an argument :"claim victory immediately when you have actually scared your opponent into not challenging your point".
When I see Dr Z arguing, I am always reminded of this.

He always asks provocative questions which belittle other religions and provides arguments that in HIS eyes, PROVE the superiority of Islam. And then, with a supercilious smile, he claims he has proved his point.

Well, if you watch the coverage, you will see that Dr Zakir Naik's audience is majority Muslim who wear their religion on their sleeve, er.. here; heads. It is intimidating to counter his arguments without risking your life, given the notorious propensity of Muslims to resort to violence over the slightest perceived affront to their religion or its originator. Your life will be certainly forfeit, because Dr Naik cannot and will not ever guarantee you immunity. Who wants to be the next Theo Van Gogh? Dr Zakir Naik is however, way quick in publicizing his 'victory'. Are people so dumb not to see through this charade, or does he plant dummies in the audience to ask him such dumb questions for which he has ready answers to?
0
Islam =Sharia=barbarity and injustice
written by Anna , December 26, 2010
I beg to differ with Mr. Khan.
Many non-believers seem to know more about Islam than most Muslims. When they do find out, many leave, or at least secretly. What kind of religion denounces other faiths, and punishes apostates? That on it's own should be enough for millions of adherents of the "religion of peace" to run a mile !
Having said that, how come, if Islam is so superior, all we see and hear today is violence and injustice in Muslim country's? Persecution of minority faiths are legion there too . In GB, according to Wikileaks, 40% of Muslims want Sharia Law instated !! What normal, secure and mentally stable person loves stone-age Sharia? none. Do you Mr. Khan, love Sharia? Do you actually even know what it means? If not, I will happily help you by showing you exactly what Sharia dictates.
0
Anna
written by duh_swami , December 26, 2010
I can't speak for Mr Khan about sharia, but I have never read where he expressed love toward it...


...40% of Muslims want Sharia Law...

I think that comes from a poll taken in the US

What I want to know is why is it that the other 60% don't want it...Is not Sharia 'Allah's laws'? Sixty percent of those polled must have been apostates...No pious Muslim would be against Allah's laws...Maybe this poll shows that there are more closet apostates than we thought...
0
to Anna
written by Mohammad.A.Khan , December 26, 2010
Miss Anna, you have full right to agree or disagree with my points.

First of all this is not true that many non-Muslims know about Islam than that of Muslims. However, there is a small bunch of group, but scattered, in Europe, America, Australia that know about Islam after exhausting research. It is because, in America, whenever I tell any American that I am from Pakistan, they don't even know where Pakistan is exactly located. Most of them even don't know about Islam and its history. They think I speak Arabic because my name is Mohammad. But in Pakistan less than 10% Muslims know Arabic. Even, I am not as fluent in Arabic as I am in other languages.

Your question, "What kind of religion denounces other faiths, and punishes apostates?" As in my article, I clearly mentioned that there were extremism in every religion, BUT, in the PAST. By extremism, I mean, the harrasment of minority groups or other religions, in Islam, is so vast so much so, Muslims are ready to kill non-Muslims. I believe that the element of prejudice and bigotry is present in every religion even today, but not as severe or threatening to harass or kill others, as Islam is doing in its own territories.

As long as shariah laws concern, it is widely known that Shariah law is derived from two sources that are Quran and the example of Muhammad, the founder of Islam. We all know what is Quran and what is not, so we will put Quran aside, because Quran has been failed in many cirucusmstances to solve the problems of normal routine life of Muslims. In this point of view, when Islam was expanding, barbarically, out of Arabia, many problems occured in the way of Muslims that Quran did not shed its light on those problems. Thus, later, Muslim scholars and rulers were in trouble to solve the problems where they adviced to device something so that they could affiliate and attribute with Muhammad, the founder of Islam; consequently, by this way, Hadiths came into existence. To cover-up many flaws and errors in Islam is also the cause of Hadiths, sira and history of Islam by Muslim historians.

btw, what do you mean by "stone-age sharia"? Yes, I would like to know about stone-age sharia, you are welcome to reply back.

Mohammad.A.Khan
0
Stone age sharia
written by duh_swami , December 26, 2010
,Stone age sharia went something like this...'I like your wife so I am going to drag her off by her hair, and have sex with her the very same night, if you don't like that, I will hit you with a large rock...Mohammad practiced a similar version...I like your wife, so I will invade your village, kill all your relatives, and have sex with her the very same night...
0
to Duh_Swami
written by Mohammad.A.Khan , December 26, 2010
...'I like your wife so I am going to drag her off by her hair, and have sex with her the very same night, if you don't like that, I will hit you with a large rock...

I think you were little harsh, than what history says. I understand your feelings.

Mohammad.A.Khan
0
one sharia or million sharias!
written by Healer_999 , December 26, 2010
I thought that there is only one sharia i.e. islamic sharia; not stone age sharia or modern sharia or medieval sharia.

I know four schools of sharia; hanafi, shafi'i, hambali, maliki. Of course shia have their own fiqh.

But Reslan says there are million sharia? Can some one enlighten on this?

Of course I know Reslan, a buddy of Robert Spencer!!!! kidding. Sorry, because just now i came to know there is no fun in islam. But i love to break islamic rules.
0
Mohammad.A.Khan
written by Reed Wilson. , December 27, 2010
You tell me that you have decided not to discuss religion with me due to my deficient knowledge. Up to you Sir! I will learn from your articles and from your posts directed to others.

I don’t think that we discussed religion with you in recent past. I am poor in politics also.
0
Mohammad.A.Khan
written by duh_swami , December 27, 2010

I think you were little harsh, than what history says.

Not harsh, just sarcastic...
The reference was about 'cave man' sharia...Really old history says that's the way cave men did it (raiding other tribes for women), but they didn't call it sharia...Mohammad also raided other tribes and took women, but he didn't call it sharia either...So there really is no such thing as 'cave man' sharia...But there is such a thing as 'cave man mentality'...Mohammad seems to have had plenty of that...
0
think about it
written by free thinker , December 28, 2010
if muslims allowed to object and speak their mind and have chance to watch quite and reasonable debates between religions many of them specialley the wise and honest will leave islam
0
...
written by free thinker , December 28, 2010
if muslims become majority in the west and that could happen soon gradually they will inforce sharia which ban music & movies & dancing & have girl or boy friend & no handshake between man and women unless if she is your wife . the women must cover all their body ... many many many more absurd rules .
fortunately the sharia is not applied in most of islamic countries only in saudi arabia & pakistan & iran .
0
...
written by duh_swami , December 28, 2010
fortunately the sharia is not applied in most of islamic countries only in saudi arabia & pakistan & iran .

You left out the US, UK, Somalia, Kenya, Nigeria, Philippines, Russia,
The UN, France, Germany, Netherlands, Egypt, and numerous other places where large numbers of Muslims live...Sharia and Islam are one and the same, and cannot be separated...In Muslim controlled countries that have secular governments a basic rule applies...'Whenever sharia and secular law conflict, sharia trumps'...
0
Stone-age Sharia
written by Archpagan , December 28, 2010
'Stone-age Sharia'? I hope you are not joking Ms Anna. Tribal people across the globe love to revel in their neolithic culture. Similarly, Muslims are enamoured to live in medieval-ism. For them, time is frozen in the 7th century C E. and all subsequent developments in the human civilization were unnecessary and pernicious.

People of different culture, civilization and Religion have their own life-philosophy. For Hindus life is MAYA i. e. illusory event or virtual reality. For Buddhists life is DUKKHA i. e. sorrow. Someone from the west summed up life as ' a tale told by an idiot'. But for Muslims life is promiscuity in a huge brothel called world.
0
Democracy nd Shitilam (islam)
written by Anil k Bali , December 29, 2010
Islam is not only a religion, but a fully developed political system just like a monarchy, communism or it can be called the dictatorship of Muhammad. This system has its laws and punishments for those who break the laws, tax system and everything to run a nation according to Muhammad’s will, and Muhammad’s will is against the freedom of mankind, women’s rights, non-Muslim rights. In short, Muhammad’s will is against democracy and human rights. In democratic countries, like America, Britain and India Muslims call themselves American-Muslim, British-Muslim and Indian-Muslim, but the truth is they lie to others at the same time they lie to themselves. Democracy means freedom in good sense, and Islam mean slavery to Muhammad. A true follower of Muhammad can never accept the idea of democracy and a true American, British, Indian or any citizen of democratic country cannot accept the idea of Islam. The word American-Muslim does not make sense. You can be American or you can be Muslim, but you never can be American Muslim. As we all know, a true Nazi cannot be a true Jew and a true Jew cannot be a Nazi. I have never heard of a ‘Nazi Jew’ or ‘Jewish Nazi’. It does not make sense at all; the same way words like American-Muslim, British-Muslim, Canadian-Muslim, Ozzy-Muslim and Indian-Muslim do not make sense. Every country faces division or fights for Islamic freedom wherever Muslim minorities exist. Soon America, Britain and many more countries will face the same trouble, which was faced by India in 1947.
0
...
written by Abu Taleb , December 29, 2010
The muslims are so proud of being stupid by boasting only Quran, among sacred texts, says what is the name of the true religion. The muslims do not realize that a true religion does not need to have a name, because a religion is simply a way to reach god(s).

It is people who give names to their religions respectively. So, if Quran says the name of the true religion, then it just proves that Quran is made by some simple minded people.

Even more stupid, Quran says the Islam is the religion of Allah (at least in the translations), so the muslims say that Allah has a religion, that makes Allah a muslim too. No wonder Quran says that Allah prays (to whom???).

Seems like no muslim ever notice this super stupid stuff.
0
to Abu Taleb
written by mohammad.A.Khan , December 30, 2010
so the muslims say that Allah has a religion, that makes Allah a muslim too. No wonder Quran says that Allah prays (to whom???).

Thats true, Allah also worship to an unknown entity because he claimed himself in the Quran and compared his characteristic with those of humans and animals and he also has a face, two hands and shin.

Now Muslims, are in trouble that their Allah resembles with humans and animals; thus, in order to play trick, they explain that Allah's hands and face and shin, described in the Quran, are not like human beings and animals. He is the most exalted and no one can reach him. I don't know what has happened to Muslim's wit. Why they can't think rationally but to make excuses to decieve their ownselves.

Mohammad.A.Khan
0
to Abu Taleb
written by mohammad.A.Khan , December 30, 2010
so the muslims say that Allah has a religion, that makes Allah a muslim too. No wonder Quran says that Allah prays (to whom???).

Thats true, Allah also worship to an unknown entity because he claimed himself in the Quran and compared his characteristic with those of humans and animals and he also has a face, two hands and shin.

Now Muslims, are in trouble that their Allah resembles with humans and animals; thus, in order to play trick, they explain that Allah's hands and face and shin, described in the Quran, are not like human beings and animals. He is the most exalted and no one can reach him. I don't know what has happened to Muslim's wit. Why they can't think rationally but to make excuses to decieve their ownselves.

Mohammad.A.Khan
0
Why is Allah afraid?
written by lw1 , December 30, 2010
What the Pope said:
In the seventh conversation .... the emperor touches on the theme of the holy war. Without descending to details, such as the difference in treatment accorded to those who have the 'Book' and the 'infidels', he addresses his interlocutor with a brusqueness on the central question about the relationship between religion and violence in general, saying:
'Show me just what Muhammad brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by sword the faith he preached'.
If the true Almighty God (not Allah) has given us freedom to think for ourselves and not be brain-washed like Muslims, it is our responsibility for the choices we make as to where we end up after death. Why should Almighty God be bothered about us? If He is bothered, then let Him make us all perfect and we can go to Heaven.
0
Rationalist
written by fineliving56 , January 02, 2011
I am asking…I already know, marrying cousins cause mental defect …it happened too many times back home and I do not see it in marriages from different blood and that is enough proof to me .
Mr. wilson .the reason Quran seems biased for men, is because it is written by men …naturally when muslim men have so many rights over women, they get to have more sex…more money…more control …what more do they need or want …please do not insult our intelligent by posting these poor and mumbled explanations for 2:282 and others like it in Quran that goes no where.
0
London Underground posters saying Mohammad gave equal rights to women-LIE
written by lw1 , January 03, 2011
2.282 O ye who believe! When ye contract a debt for a fixed term, record it in writing between you (in terms of) equity. No scribe shall refuse to write as Allah hath taught him, so let him write, and let him who incurreth the debt dictate, and let him observe his duty to Allah his Lord, and diminish not thereof. But if he who oweth the debt is of low understanding, or weak, or unable himself to dictate, then let the guardianof his interests dictate in (terms of) equity. AND CALL TWO WITNESSES FROM AMONG YOUR MEN, TWO WITNESSES. AND IF TWO MEN BE NOT AT HAND, THEN A MAN AND TWO WOMEN, of such as ye approve as witnesses, SO THAT IF ONE ERRETH(THROUGH FORGETFULNESS) THE OTHER WILL REMEMBER. And the witnesses must not refuse when they are summoned. .......
This is a big insult to women. Muslims boast 'We have had country leaders who are women'. That is completely against Quran.
Women, how can you bear to be Muslim?
0
100,000 Britons have chosen to become Muslim... and average convert is 27-year-old white woman
written by Helper , January 05, 2011
0
...
written by eddy , January 11, 2011
Another reason why I left Islam is that Quran is full of internal contradictions, scientific errors and historical blunders. Muslims claim that Quran is ‘a miracle of miracles.’ This statement is a blatant and greatest lie ever told. Here are a few samples of contradictions in Quran: examples of internal contradictions-- 54:19 mentions Aad was destroyed in a day but 69:6,7 mentions Aad was destroyed in seven nights and eight days; 19:17 shows an angel appeared to Mary but 3:42 shows several angels appeared; 28:40 mentions pharaoh drowned and died but 10:92 states that the same pharaoh was saved; examples of scientific errors--18:86 states that sun sets in a muddy spring of water; 15:19 mentions earth is flat; 86:6,7 states that semen emits from between back-bone and the ribs; examples of historical blunders—19:27,28 states that Mary was the sister of Aaron, whereas history shows they were born about 1300 years apart; 28:8 tells that pharaoh and Haman were living at the same time and place whereas history clearly shows they were born about 1000 years apart and pharaoh lived in Egypt and Haman lived in Shushan city in Persia; and 4:157 says that Jesus was not crucified whereas it is crystal clear in historical records that Jesus was crucified and not another man who looked like Jesus. By the way, the transliterated name of Jesus in arabic Quran is Isa but even this is wrong because the name of Esau, brother of Jacob (Yaqub in arabic) is Isa in arabic. The correct transliterated name of Jesus in arabic is Yasu. Isa (Esau) means ‘hairy’ and Yasu (Jesus) means ‘God saves.’ Muslims tell so many lies to cover up all internal contradictions, scientific errors and historical blunders in Quran. Any sane person can become sick of Muslim apologists’ deception and lies of ‘out of context,’ ‘bad translation’ and ‘arabic Quran can not be translated’ to hide and conceal the contradictions in the Quran.
0
to eddy
written by Mohammad.A.Khan , January 11, 2011
Congratulations on leaving the cult Islam and welcome to humanity

have a nice day!

Mohammad.A.Khan

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comments.

busy
 

About the book || Reviews by: Steven Simpson | Abul Kasem | Prof Sami Alrabaa | Ibn Kammuna

islamic-jihad-cover


'Islamic Jihad' in Bangla
islamic-jihad-bangla
Aasma Riaz: "Thank you so much for your book "Islamic Jihad" and showing me the "Big Picture". For 7-8 days, I was glued to your book, absorbing so much information that I did not know existed. You have crisply covered so much in your book and quoted historical references extensively. I am just overwhelmed with different emotions after reading your book..., a priceless tome."

Editor: M A Khan | Site design: Dan Zaremba
Founded on 20 November 2005


Announcements

Sign petition:  Grant Imran Firasat Asylum in the USA

imran-firasat

Proxy Server: To view blocked websites, use this: iwebproxy

Syndication