Islam
Under Scrutiny by Ex-Muslims
Thailand: Islamist Insurgency with No End, Part 1
19 May, 2007
For
more than three years, the south of Thailand has
seen an insurgency which has now claimed more than 2,100 lives. On
January 4, 2004, a military base in Narathiwat province was
raided, and four soldiers were killed. In the raid, more than 300
weapons were stolen, including AK-47 and M-16 rifles. On the same
night, at least 20 schools were set ablaze - the "night of the
fires". This event signaled the start of the current insurgency.
The last major insurgency before this had taken place in the
1980s.
The three southern provinces of Pattani, Narathiwat and Yala, as
well as some districts of Songkhla province and the small island
of Satun are predominantly Muslim. Here the population is 80%
Muslim, most of whom speak Yawi, a Malay dialect. Historically
Pattani, Narathiwat, Yala and two districts of Songkhla were part
of an independent sultanate called Pattani.
In 1786, this sultanate had been invaded by Siam (Thailand) and
in 1902, the region became officially annexed into Siam. This was
done primarily to create a buffer against the influence of the
British, who controlled Malaya. In 1909, Britain officially
acknowledged the provinces as being part of Siam. The current
insurgency is one of many that have taken place over the past
fifty years but it is, by far, the most savage in its execution.
Though there have been horrific cases of sectarian killings, with
Buddhists being decapitated or burned alive, Muslims are equally
likely to be victims of the insurgents. Any who are seen to be
"assisting" the government, including schoolteachers and village
heads, are potential targets.
The aim of some prominent insurgent groups in the south of
Thailand is to secede from Thailand. Others, such as the five
groups forming the
Barisan Bersatu Kemerdekaan Pattani
coalition now claim only to seek better treatment of Muslims in
the south. It is true that Thailand's military has in the past
been
over-zealous in
trying to control elements in the south.
Under
the last government of the Thai Rak Party, led by Thaksin
Shinawatra (pictured) two events caused particular animosity. The
first case happened on March 12, 2004. Muslim lawyer Somchai
Neelapaijit, who was representing people arrested since the
current insurgency began, was abducted at a parking lot in
Bangkok. Witnesses saw him being bundled by policemen into a car.
He was never seen again.
On
January 12, 2006,
a senior policeman, Major Nguen Thongsuk, was found guilty of
illegally detaining Somchai. He was sentenced to three years'
jail. Four other policemen were acquitted. The day after Thongsuk
was convicted, then-prime minister Thanksin Shinawatra made a
curious
statement: "I know
that Somchai is dead, and more than four government officials were
involved, but witnesses and evidence are still being collected."
The
other event to incite bitter feeling in the Muslim population was
the Tak Bai massacre of October 25, 2004. A demonstration led by
farmers and villagers took place in Tak Bai, Narathiwat province.
The demonstrators sought the release of six village defense
volunteers, who had been arrested for suspected gun theft. Police
opened fire on the protesters, killing seven people. The
demonstrators were forced to lie face down on the ground, stripped
to the waist, and were then loaded into trucks. In some trucks,
they were in layers, four persons deep. All were placed face down,
with their hands tied behind their backs. The trucks were then
driven to Ingkhayuthaboriharn camp in Pattani province. In the
sweltering heat, at least 78 people suffocated. Within a month 30
Buddhists were
killed in apparent
revenge attacks.
On
September 17, 2006,
following months of nationwide protests against Shinawatra's
government, the army staged a bloodless coup while the prime
minister was away at a UN meeting in New York. The leader of the
coup was a Muslim, General Sonthi Boonyaratkalin, who had headed
the Fourth Amy in the south. He was assumed to understand the
insurgency. He set up a caretaker government on October 1, led by
"prime minister" Surayud Chulanont, with a Muslim interior
minister, Aree Wong-araya. The new government promised to adopt a
more conciliatory approach in the south, even at one stage
offering Muslims the opportunity to govern themselves under
sharia law. Seven
months on from the coup, and though conciliation is still
advocated by prime
minister Chulanont, it has been a failure.
Figures reported in the Bangkok Post of May 17 this week
state that compared to last year, the incidence of violent attacks
has slightly dropped, but the savagery has increased. Between
January 1 and May 15 this year, there have been 1,170 incidents,
compared to 2,061 in the same period in 2006. Half of this year's
attacks have involved shootings, a quarter has employed bombs, and
arson has accounted for 15% of attacks.
Before last year's coup, incidents of beheadings had lessened.
There were 7 decapitations from
November, 2005 to
March 2006. After a Muslim rubber tapper named Abdulaziz Japakiya
was decapitated on
March 7, 2006,
there were no such incidents until
October 12. On
this date a 45-year old Burmese migrant worker was attacked while
on his motorcycle with his daughter behind him, in Pattani
province. The girl was blindfolded as Yao, her father, was shot
and then beheaded. The head was carried 12 miles to their village,
where it was booby trapped with a bomb. Yao had been the twentieth
person to be decapitated in the current insurgency. On Sunday
November 19, a
Buddhist man was shot in Yala. His killers tried to remove his
head, but left it more or less attached.
Since the coup, decapitations have escalated, easily seen as
dramatic gestures of hate. On Sunday
March 11, six
Burmese construction workers were shot dead in Nong Chick, Pattani
province. One of these was beheaded, the 26th individual to be
treated this way since January 2004. A note on the man's body was
left behind, reading: "Kill the innocent and we kill Thai
Buddhists."
On Monday,
May 14 this week,
a Buddhist husband and wife were picking fruit in Yala province,
accompanied by their three-year old daughter. The two adults were
shot dead, and the small girl was injured. The head of 36-year old
Prapham Ponlarak was removed in front of his child. He had become
the 29th person to be beheaded in the insurgency.
The insurgents have been claimed by Thai officials to be
motivated by local concerns, suggesting that there is little
outside influence. Certain facts undermine this. The group
Jemaah Islamiyah (JI)
seeks to establish an Islamist "superstate" in southeast Asia.
This group has known links to Al Qaeda and to other Islamist
terror groups, such as Abu Sayyaf and Darul Islam. JI was founded
in Malaysia around
1995 by two
Indonesian clerics, Abdullah Sungkar (died in 1999) and Abu Bakar
Bashir. The two had founded the Ngruki or
Al Mukmin Muslim
seminary in Solo, about 250 miles east of Jakarta, Indonesia.
According to JI expert Dr Sidney Jones of the International Crisis
Group, at least 30 known or suspected terrorists have graduated
from this school.
One
leader of JI was Hambali (pictured), also known as Riduan
Isamuddin. He was caught in Thailand on
August 11, 2003 in
Ayutthaya, 50 miles north of Bangkok. Hambali ran the Hudaybiyah
terror training camp in the Philippines. He was suspected of being
involved in
Operation Bojinka,
a plot to bomb 11 US commercial planes in southeast Asia. He was
transferred to Guantanamo in
September 2006.
Hambali is believed to have planned the Bali bombings of October
12, 2002, in which 202 people died. He revealed under
interrogation that
while he plotted these attacks, he had stayed for three days in
the south of Thailand, with hardline cleric Dr Ismail Lutfi. This
cleric runs the Yala Islamic College, which teaches Saudi
Wahhabism. Lutfi had been educated at the Muhammad bin Saud
Islamic University in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. This institution has
educated extremists such as
Abdullah el-Faisal,
currently in jail in Britain for soliciting murder. Lutfi denied
any meetings with Hambali.
When lawyer Somchai Neelapaijit was abducted in Bangkok in March
2004,
two of his clients
were Jemaah Islamiyah members who had been accused of plotting
bomb attacks in Thailand. These two individuals were finally
acquitted in July 2005.
The head of the coalition of five insurgent groups - Barisan
Bersatu Kemerdekaan Pattani (Bersatu) - is Wan Kadir Che Wan. His
group is among the insurgents who have participated in peace talks
with the post-coup government of Thailand, which have been
brokered by former
Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohammed's Perdana Global Peace
Foundation. On
November 21 last
year, Wan Kadir Che Wan claimed that Jemaah Islamiyah was
influencing the younger generation of insurgents. He said: "I
think that many of the groups are there but maybe they are not
directly involved."
Immediately after the current insurgency began, then-prime
minister Thaksin Shinawatra ordered an
investigation into
the activities of Islamic schools (called pondok) in the
south of Thailand. There are 300 such schools in the southern
provinces. One of these institutions, the Thamma Wittaya school in
Yala city, Yala province, has a strong relation with the current
violence. Six of its teachers have been killed in the current
insurgency. It was founded by Sapaeing Bazo, leader of the
insurgent group Barisan Revolusi Nasional Coordinate.
In
March 2006, 19
teachers from the Thamma Wittaya were arrested after holding a
meeting on Satun island. They were subsequently
released without
charge. Sapaeing Bazo is believed to be hiding across the border
in Malaysia. He has a bounty of 10 million Thai baht ($256,227)
against him.
Another prominent member of Barisan Revolusi Nasional Coordinate
is called Masae Useng, who was trained in Afghanistan. Useng is
believed to have ordered a campaign of mass bombings which
occurred in the south for three days, beginning on
June 15 last year
- so-called "National Pattani Day". On
July 13, a month
after these bombings, Malaysia's defense minister, Najib Tun Razak,
met with Thaksin Shinawatra. Najib said that attempts to find
Masae Useng had failed, and it was assumed that he was now in the
Middle East. The deputy Thai Prime Minister claimed after these
talks that it was believed four or five other insurgent leaders
were thought to be hiding in the Middle East. No specific country
was named.
Another pondok school with links to extremism is the
Hutae Tua pondok
in Narathiwat. This school is run by a veteran of Afghanistan
fighting, Muhammad Haji Jaeming (Abdul Fatah). He is responsible
for founding a separatist group called Jemaah Salafi or Jemaah
Salafiya.
The presence of Wahhabism in southern Thailand is still small,
but it appears to be playing a part in radicalizing young people
who go on to become insurgents. The issue of who directly funds
the insurgents is not entirely clear, but it appears some
logistical and financial support comes from non-government sources
in Malaysia. On
November 21, 2006,
prime minister Surayud Chulanont claimed that the main source of
insurgent funding came from a chain of Thai restaurants operating
in Malaysia, which sold Thai spicy shrimp soup. These claims were
denied by
Malaysia's Deputy Security Minister Fu Ah Kiow, who called them
"baseless".
One of the several groups which has played a part in insurgent
activity is
Gerakan Mujahideen Islam Pattani
or GMIP. This group has links with a small Malaysian extremist
group - Kumpulan
Mujahideen Malaysia - which seeks to
establish an Islamist state in southeast Asia. GMIP was founded in
1986. In 1999 to 2000, GMIP was
approached by
Jemaah Islamiyah. JI wanted GMIP to become
allies within the
umbrella group of Islamist bodies known as Rabibat-ul-Mujahidin.
Though GMIP is described as a criminal organization, whether it
accepted JI's offer is not known.
Though not directly tied to terrorism, Saudi Arabia has certainly
been pouring money into Muslim institutions in the south of
Thailand, and promoting its narrow and uncompromising
interpretation of Islam. Ismail Lutfi of the Islamic College of
Yala, whom Hambali claimed to know, is a board member of the
Muslim World League. This has led to Saudi funds being sent to his
college. Another group in the south
receiving funds
from Saudi Arabia and the Gulf is the Pusaka foundation, which is
ostensibly an educational body. It has, however, been accused of
links with the Thai insurgency. One politician, a former member of
Thaksin Shinawatra's Thai Rak Thai party, who was involved with
Pusaka, is
Najmuddin Umar.
Umar was suspected of involvement in the January 4, 2004 raid
upon the military base, which kick-started the insurgency. He was
charged on
10 counts,
including treason, separatist activities, arson, robbery and
murder of government officials. He was sent to trial in October
2004, but in
December 2005, he
was eventually acquitted due to lack of evidence.
Adrian Morgan is a
British based writer and artist who regularly contributes in
Family Security Matters. His essays also appear in
Western Resistance,
Spero News and
Faithfreedom.org.