Islam Under Scrutiny by Ex-Muslims

Muhammad the Fief Distributor

My grandmother used to tell me stories of Prophet Muhammad in my childhood; these were commonly about his tolerance, kindness, virtues and love for animals etc.? She told me that our prophet was very simple; he led simple life. He never made any castle; he spent his life in simple house. He used to sleep on floor. But the Muhammad that exists in my grandmother’s mind never exists in history.
Muhammad was an orphan. He used to look after the goats of his grand father. Before his marriage to Khadija, he was nothing. All the stories which Muslims always recall are of the Meccan period of Muhammad's life when he was nothing, has nothing. He started drama of simplicity etc. to attract the Meccan people.

But after snatching the properties of the Jews of medina, he did all to satisfy his ego. But why did he not make any palace or castle? Answer is very simple. It was not customary to make huge palaces and building in Arabia in general. Muhammad was a simple pagan of Arabic desert before his drama of prophethood. So he was not having such a mentality to make palaces etc. The only wish which he could have was to have a collection of women in his harem.

We Indians, sometimes wonders about the wealth and property of Mughal rulers of the subcontinent. There are many stories about the wealth and generosity. But Muhammad was of mould of the Mughals.

Narrated By Abdullah ibn Umar: The Prophet (pbuh) gave az-Zubayr the land as a fief up to the reach of his horse when he runs. He, therefore, made his horse run until it stopped. He then threw his flog. Thereupon he said: Give him (the land) up to the point where his flog has reached. (13: 3066.abu dawud)

Above hadith is self-explaining, but one thing I always think is that check out the mentality of greedy follower of the greedy prophet. He threw his flog to get some meters of land more.

This hadith always reminds me the stories of 'fief distribution' among the Mughal emperors.

Here are some more ahadiths.

Narrated By Alqamah ibn Wa'il : The Prophet (pbuh) bestowed land in Hadramawt as fief. (13:3052abu dawud)

Narrated By Abyad ibn Hammal : Abyad went to the Apostle of Allah (pbuh) and asked him for assigning him (the mines of) salt as fief. (The narrator Ibn al-Mutawakkil said: which was in Ma'arib.)

So he assigned it to him as a fief. When he returned, a man in the meeting asked: Do you know what you have assigned him as a fief? You have assigned him the perennial spring water. So he took it back from him. He asked him about protecting land which had arak trees growing in it. He replied: He could have such as been beyond the region where the hoofs (of camels) went. (13:3058abu dawud)

I studied a good deal of history, but I never come across any incident amongst Mughals that some one have given so much costly thing as fief. But here Muhammad seems surpass to the examples in history. He was undoubtedly a great fief-distributor and looter in history.

Narrated By Asmar ibn Mudarris: I came to the Prophet (pbuh), and took the oath of allegiance to him. He said: If anyone reaches a water which has not been approached before by any Muslim, it belongs to him. The people, therefore, went out running and marking (on the land). (13:3065abu dawud)

Just imagine the scene, when Muslims would be running and marking the land to snatch from Jews of khaiber. What scene should be there? What would the Jews thinking about the Muhammad? How could any fair and just God allow any one to snatch and loot in such a way?

Actually point is that ,my grandmother hasn’t yet read Quran and hadith but I have. So I always listen her carefully and smile that how much Muslims are away from reality.

Narrated By AbuHurayrah: The Prophet (pbuh) said: A fifth is payable on buried treasure. (13:3079abu dawud)


If you like this essay: Stumble it   Stumble Upon Toolbar digg it reddit

Amar Khan is a Pakistan-born ex-Muslim.

Name:     closed


Comment Notes: Keep comments short. Our system cannot separate paragraphs.

Comments must be relevant to the topic of the article. We do not regulate the comments but if irrelevant comments, materials, adds of other websites etc. are being uploaded, we may ban such nuisance posters.

Name: nademaslam36
Date: Thursday December 04, 2008
Time: 22:29:50 -0500


well amarkhan i am muslim by choice its just ur misled prpoganda ur jews agent ISLAM N MUHAMAD PBUH NO ONE HAS SEEN RELIGION LIKE ISLAM?learn from me or scholars

Name: islamists try to glorify falsely the mad maniac
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 00:39:31 -0500


islamists try to glorify falsely the mad maniac.Mo was full of evils and lea amorla and incest maniac life.He assumed his schizo hallucinations are revelations of god.This shos blindly believing of self claiming gods or gods prophets is dangerous.

Name: RE:nademaslam36 from Ibrahim lone
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 01:05:54 -0500


Since you think you are you are a big scholar, why dont you write an article and prove your words rather than filling this Forum with your gibbereish. If you think you are so intelligent. Come and debate with the people on this Forum and then let us see who is right. This is an open challege. If you loose you will publically declare your aposatcy if we loose alteast I will become Muslim again. So what do you say brother?

Name: jackiebrownstone
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 01:25:07 -0500


Here's hoping "Disturbed internet trolls desperate for a social outlet will soon move on to other places to play than this forum".

Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 01:44:22 -0500


to : all muslims who make false claim that allah created man so he must be worshipped : man is not created by any false imaginary allah,but evolved by nature the true god,from 1 celled organisms,and proof is in our genes and worship truth=nature,not imaginary arab deity allah.also a very interesting fact : ITS KNOWN FACT THAT MAN HAS X-Y CHROMOSOMES AND WOMAN HAS Y-Y CHROMOSOMES.if allah created man he must hv x-y chromosomes,and if allah created woman from man who has y-y chromosomes from where this imaginary allah got the extra y chromosome for women ? same way fake book koran claims that jesus is virgin born,if so and if jesus is male,then from where di his "x" chromosome come ? did allah grow testicles to penetrate mary ? muslims dont give false answers pls give only truth based answers.u will realise that all claims of quran r based on falsehood that allah created man,but once u udnerstand truth that jehova/allah did not create man,u will understand its just another FAIRY TALE BOOK.dont believe in koran berlieve only in truth

Name: why arabs hate idols ? bcoz they cant compete to kafirs in arts-that's why !!!
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 02:53:54 -0500


arabs-muslims and their followers want tod estroy art,poetry,music etc...why...i alwayes wondered...then finally i knew why : these r desert religion,and here there is little or no art at all,and when they see the beautiful art of akfirs-pagans they r unable to bear the fact that someone can be superior to them in arts etc.thus they want to destroy all music,singing,etc...all things which r better than arab culture needs to be destroyed so that the desert barren lifestyle of the arabs can be imposed on the world.just bcoz they cant do or appreciate atr they dotn want anyone to do it or enjoy it.thus taliban etc...r banning it.

Name: can god take human form ?? sure he can !!!!
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 02:55:59 -0500


if there is a god,who is all powerful,can he take human form ? sure he can if he is all powerful. who r muslims to stop the god from taking any form human or animal ? if muslims say god who is all powerful cant take human form they r saying that god is not all powerful,and it means they r theslf blasphemising god.and the penalty for blasphemy is death,so kill all those who dont believe god can take human form.

Name: Non Muslim
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 09:22:53 -0500


Muhammad was a despicable maffia leader, a man who ordered his minions to steal, kill and extort (jizya) Sirat Rasul Allah Page 607: "Then the apostle summoned Khalid ibn al-Walid and sent him to Ukaydir at Duuma. Ukaydir ibn ‘Abdu’l-Malik was was a man of Kinda who was ruler of Duuma; he was a Christian. The apostle told Khaalid that he would find him hunting cows. Khaalid went of until he came within sight of his fort. It was a summer night with a bright moon and Ukaydir was on the roof with his wife. The cows were rubbing their horns against the gate of the fort all the night. His wife asked him if he had ever known anything of the kind in the past, and urged to go after them. He called for his horse, and when it was saddled he rode off with a number of his family, among them a brother called Hassaan. As they were riding the apostle’s cavalry fell in with them and seized him and killed his brother. Ukaydir was wearing a gown of brocade covered with gold. Khaalid stripped him of this and sent it to the apostle before he brought him to him. ’Asim ibn ‘Umar ibn Qataada from Anas ibn Maalik said: I saw Ukaydir’s gown when it was brought to the apostle. The Muslims were feeling it and admiring it, and the apostle said, ‘Do you admire this? By Him in whose hands is my life the napkins of Sa’d ibn Mu’adh in Paradise are better than this.’ The Khaalid brought Ukaydir to the apostle who spared his life and made peace with him on condition that he paid the poll tax. The he released him and he returned to his town."

Name: Re: nademaslam36
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 10:09:16 -0500


"ur jews agent" - lol. You must be one of Islam's top scholars. Can anyone explain what this goofball means by no one has seen a religion like Islam? Does he think Islam is original? How can a Jew or a Christian honestly read the Koran and not think, "This is a complete ripoff." And Mohammed claimed he received his message from Gabriel just like the Virgin Mary. I wonder if Mohammed thought of himself as an important WOMAN in other ways.

Name: Honey
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 13:56:46 -0500


Hi aamir.....for u i can only say Little knowledge is always dangerous........iam sure you were a bad student at school.

Name: G.Ryan
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 15:10:44 -0500


To the mad muslim,you are a bigot by choice and a bloody foolish one at that!

Name: kafir/infidel ( & Ex-communist ).
Date: Friday December 05, 2008
Time: 16:10:41 -0500


Nobody on this earth should have any problem calling - ISLAM is a dark chapter in human history. Alla is preislamic moon God - appropriated by jealousied, envious MO in his schyzoprenic hallucinations , in order to make his tribe superior to jews and christians. Mo was a thug and a looter, robber, lecher, pedophile, killer, hate monger, evil, extremely cruel monster with mediocritic intelligence. Why did Mo get envious of jews and christians at that time in ARABIA in 7th century ? Because , Mo saw both judaism and christianity were growing and spreading fast at that time. Then he developed this cleverly - revelations, one book, one last prophet business to make his tribe dominant, supremacist with hegemony. He did everything to achive this goal by any means . and Mo succeeded in eliminating, judaism and christianity in and around ARABIA . MO_HAM_MAD was was an extremely evil, cruel,hate monger ,bigot and deadly . Therfore - ISLAM - which is Mo's imagination reflects all dark, evil,cruel,bigotted ,perverse theology. There is no spirituality in ISLAM. No earth shaking or profound ideas or philosophy or ethos or values . Mo- being devoid of any thing original and a fake prophet ( profiteer ) did not bring anything new - but just simply copied from judaism and christianity . In fact - whatever Mo , popularised for Moslems - like ZIZIYA tax, fatwas, Jihads, apostacy,Houris, dhimmi, kafir, infidel, mushkreen, darul harb - are all dark and appeal to the base and evil instincts of humans. MO was sex maniac - otherwise what explains in a religious way - QQURRAN is filled and obsessed with sex and Mo reduced women as sex robots !!!! MO also originated, perpetrated, promoted slavery. Any good human being with integrity, truth, pure conscience ,with good heart and mind will be ashamed to call MO as prophet or QQURRAN as anything good ( other than sewage waste ) will be definitly ashamed and repulse at ISLAM. It is better even this late , that the humanity wakes up and rejects and burn QQURRAN and flush ISLAM into sewage.

Name: Flush Islam into the Sewage
Date: Sunday December 14, 2008
Time: 12:54:07 -0500


Flush Islam into the Sewage is a very fitting description for mankind's modern day plague, fit for total eradication for humanity's sake.

Hit Counter