Islam Under Scrutiny by Ex-Muslims

Review of Tamil Edition of Understanding Muhammad: Psycho-biography of Allah’s Prophet by Ali Sina

This review can be taken as a review of the English Edition as well as for its Tamil (2nd) version.

This is perhaps the first book of its type in the world ever authored by Dr. Ali Sina, subjecting Muhammad to modern scientific psycho-analysis, solely based on, and with references from, original Islamic Holy texts: Quran, aHadiths (Sunnah, Traditions) and prophetic Sira (biographies).

As Dr. Ali Sina has written so vividly, that the people would easily realise how the concepts of Islam based on Holy Books were the spontaneous overflow of a sociopath/psychopath Muhammad to meet his own selfish needs and impulses to suit his nature.

But Dr. Ali Sina finally entreats the Muslims to join the main stream of entire world to co-exist in peace with all others by casting away their Islamic garb, which is tutoring the Muslims into terrorism and violence. He only wants the concept of Islam to be destroyed. He bears no ill-will to anyone.

This is not at all a book to be just brushed aside (as usually done only by Islamic fanatics) as preaching hatred against Muslims, but should be considered as a book of unimpeachable and convincing facts. My statement can be confirmed by any reader of this book, once he reads the entire contents of the book. This will leave on the readers stunned with a chilling effect.

Surely this book is bound to create an unprecedented revolution & ripples and shake the very foundation of Islamic edifice based on slippery grounds. Islam succeeded so long in surviving based only on autocracy silencing all criticism from any quarter, whether from Muslims or non-Muslims only by violence and terrorism. If democracy or any form of criticism would have been allowed, Islam would have ceased to exist very long time ago.

This Tamil version is a ‘Must read book’ for all Tamil people (buy it from Amazon).

Mona Malik Mustafa, the Tamil Translator, deserves special Kudos for her communicative written skills to produce the best Translation so faithful to the English original. This I can say with utmost confidence because I have read both the English and the Tamil versions very carefully.

The Tamil Translation is very superb with Translator’s comments wherever necessary. This is an added attraction for Tamil masses who are told in such a way as they speak or understand.

Why I beseech people to read this book for the following reasons:

The prophet of Islam bragged, “I have been made victorious with terror". [Sahih al-Bukhari: 4.52.220] This same process inaugurated by the Muhammad in Madina then, is still continued for the past 1400 years by his faithful followers even to this day.

Islam is Muhammadanism and Muhammadanism is Islam. Islamic Mind is nothing but the mind of Muhammad. In fact Islam is the brainchild of Muhammad. Whatsoever he so revealed or said or did on various occasions and to various people, were recorded meticulously by all Sahih Hadiths and Sunnahs / Siras uniformly apart from his own so-called revelations through Qur’an, are considered, as Holiest of Holiest by all Muslims throughout the world. Whatever written in these Holy books have become the Shariat Law too as applicable to all Muslims!! If all Sahih Hadiths and Sunnah can uniformly write the same subject in different forms without change in the central subject, viz., Muhammad, it cannot be construed as untrue. These incidents might have been true definitely. Such statements alone have been considered in this book for the purpose of references.

This book of Psycho-biography of Allah’s prophet, unveils the hidden mysteries of one of the most influential, controversial and enigmatic personalities of the world. Once Muhammad came running home, shivering with fright believing that he was possessed by demons, his wife Khadijah convinced him just to satisfy and quietening him for the moment that he had became Allah’s prophet. But he took it seriously and he liked this name, title and role too. Thereafter, he started living and behaving like Prophet of Allah.

His childhood was very miserable as he was born after his father’s death and mother was too poor to meet both ends. He was brought up in a love-less atmosphere of an orphan, as a child. After the death of his mother subsequently, though he was reared by his grandfather, and finally his Uncle with love and affection, he could not overcome his childhood indelible memories and fantasies. His marriage with the rich lady, Khadijah was more convenient live his chosen way of life. This was a beginning of his developing narcissist mentality, which in later life fully blossomed into a full Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD). Thus he believed that he must be obeyed unquestionably, brook no opposition, and at the same time wanted to be extolled at all times.

Besides the above he had Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE), since he was living in his own world of fantasy and its idiosyncrasies which he developed during infancy.

Next, he was suffering from Obsessive Compulsory Disorder (OCD), as he was very much obsessive with rituals, and performing them meticulously with a particular pattern in an odd number if times. He was ever enforcing, very demanding, and made his followers to follow them very strictly and scrupulously. You can observe this from his absurd rules in all walks of Islamic life.

More cruelly, Muhammad had Acromegaly very late in his life, a disease caused by excessive production of a particular hormone, resulting in large bones, cold and fleshy hands and feet, coarse facial features such as enlarged lips and nose. This disease unfortunately resulted in impotence but with awfully intensified libido. This created panic in his personal life style of sexual indulgence with all his number of wives, very many concubines and innumerable slave women. As he was by nature very jealous, greedy, and very possessive, he fancied that his women might be seeking sexual satisfaction with someone other than himself under these circumstances. So, Muhammad ordered Hijab / Nijab / Naqaab as a rule for his women. This was so recorded in the Holy Islamic books, thereby the Islamic world started this rule of veiling their women and came into vogue in Islamic life. So, this malady had been in Islamic trend for the past 1400 years. You can understand now why the half a billion Muslimas (women in Islam) of the world, have to veil themselves simply because, Muhammad was unable to copulate being an impotent man. What can be a worst tragedy to all Muslim women?

The compounding and combining effect of all the above deadly psychological disorders of Allah’s prophet, Muhammad had in fact, has resulted in the Islamic miseries of 20% of world’s population of Muslims afflicting the other 80 % of non-Islamic world population too.

We now live in perilous contemporary world. With one-fifth of World’s population being Islamic which praises eloquently a sociopath / psychopath who had only preached murder, loot, rape and terror and all other similar detested acts by any civilized society but still followed with fastidious precision by his followers to the hilt, is now violently determined to make the life of four-fifth of non-Islamic population’s life miserable and unsafe in this planet. Are we not living now in an era of unsafe life on this earth?

This psychopath Muhammad has ordained the followers that giving-up one’s own life for looting, raping and terrorizing non-Muslim as an act of Jihad, which entails automatic admission to Jannat, the Allah’s heaven wherein every martyr is supplied with 72 young crystal-like girls called ‘Houris’ solely for fulltime sex and young boys for sodomy with wine flowing in a river for easy consumption at all times and many other comforts which a normal human earthling can never even hope to dream on earth. Another funny aspect of this is, these comforts are strictly prohibited by Muhammad for tellurians.

Just imagine if Atomic weapons are also made available in the hands of this terrorist Islamic world, the whole world will become just a junk heap. Do you really and consciously want it?

Another miserable fact is that in the open democratic world, migrated Islamic population making use of full democratic way of life easily available to them is doing only undemocratic acts consistently in the migrated countries, which they cannot do it in their own native Islamic countries.

All the above are not gaffes but proved with authoritative quotes from extracted references to the authentic Islamic Holy books of Qur’an, aHadiths, and Sunnahs vis-à-vis with quotes from modern scientific giants like Dr. Sam Vaknin, W.R. Van Furth, I.G. Wolteink-Donselaar and J.M. Van Ree, (The Netherlands), Dr. Rhawan Joseph, Henri Jean Pascal, Gastuat (French Neurologist) Dr. V.S. Ramachandran, Director of Center of Brain and Cognition, Calif., etc., with other research papers.

Can anyone ask for more and better proofs?

There is none needed to shame and slam Islam, but the Islamic Holy books themselves, so created out of mind of one psychopath Muhammad, will do it most convincingly and admirably. This book is just a beginning to enlighten the world towards this direction. This book will just kindle the raging fire inside already simmering.

This book:” Understanding Muhammad: A psychobiography of Allah’s Prophet” both in English and Tamil to the respective readers, gives all the above facts convincingly and leave you thinking that you can also contribute your mite to the cause as propounded by Dr. Ali Sina, i.e. wiping out Islamic mentality from the face of this world in about twenty years.

When asked whether Islam has a future, Dr. Ali Sina’s response is: “Yes! It belongs in the dustbin of history.” (p. iv)

Oh! World! Awake, arise and stop not till Islamic mentality is done away with to create a peaceful world.


The author lives in the US.

If you like this essay: Stumble it   Stumble Upon Toolbar digg it reddit

Name:     closed


Comments Notes: Keep comments short. Our system cannot separate paragraphs. Comments must be relevant to the topic of the article. We try not to regulate the comments, but if irrelevant comments, materials, adds of other websites etc. are being uploaded, we may ban such nuisance posters.

Name: sat-chit-ananda
Date: Thursday January 22, 2009
Time: 13:27:30 -0500


Great news! Would be wonderful if a Malayalam translation were also made

Date: Thursday January 22, 2009
Time: 14:52:00 -0500


I DISAGREE WITH YOUR FOLLOWING QUOTE>>>The prophet of Islam bragged, “I have been made victorious with terror". [Sahih al-Bukhari: 4.52.220] XXXXXAND HERE IS THE SAME QUOTE IN FULL CONTEXT...DEAR READERS AS THE AUTHOR OF THE ABOVE BOOK SAID""My statement can be confirmed by any reader of this book, once he reads the entire contents of the book. This will leave on the readers stunned with a chilling effect""" NOW THIS DOES APPLY TO THE AUTHOR TO QUOTE ANY VERSE/HADITH IN FULL CONTEXT FOR ONE TO UNDERSTAND. Bukhari :: Book 4 :: Volume 52 :: Hadith 220 Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle said, "I have been sent with the shortest expressions bearing the widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with terror (cast in the hearts of the enemy), and while I was sleeping, the keys of the treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand." Abu Huraira added: Allah's Apostle has left the world and now you, people, are bringing out those treasures (i.e. the Prophet did not benefit by them).

Name: IK
Date: Thursday January 22, 2009
Time: 15:28:04 -0500


Well said brother. Thank you. I am all for translating Sina's work into all languages. There is none better to combat islam but truth

Name: Muhammad and the Quran
Date: Thursday January 22, 2009
Time: 16:06:48 -0500


It is the Quran that may reveal much about Muhammads soul. The style is so lengthy, boring and swanky that the author appears to be a typical megalomaniac. Very often we can realise that the author does not understand what he is talking about, but he still believes to know anything better than others. He has no idea how wrong and how boring he is and he does not understand anything about theology. For example, the account of the young Jesus, who makes little birds from mud was clearly drawn from apokryhal christian sources well known as Childhood Gospel of Thomas. This was written to UNDERLINE that jesus is the son of god by demonstrating that he was capable of creating living creatures from mud in the same way god allegedly created humans. However, Islam strictly opposes the view that Jesus is the son of god!

Name: jenn
Date: Thursday January 22, 2009
Time: 16:13:53 -0500


i am glad that this child rapist/murderer named Mohammad is been exposed in the Tamil language as well. Copies of the book must be sold in sri lankan bookshops because all the muslims in sri lanka speak Tamil. Ali sina has done a great job

Name: infidel
Date: Thursday January 22, 2009
Time: 18:18:13 -0500


there is no question that the Quaran is a Hoax and Mohamm was a sick man (demon possed).

Name: kope
Date: Thursday January 22, 2009
Time: 19:25:04 -0500


During the centuries of the crusades, all sorts of slanders were invented against Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). But with the birth of the modern age, marked with religious tolerance and freedom of thought, there has been a great change in the approach of Western authors in their delineation of his life and character. The views of some non-Muslim scholars regarding Prophet Muhammad, given at the end, justify this opinion.

Name: to Kope
Date: Thursday January 22, 2009
Time: 22:49:23 -0500


Let me suggest you read just the first chapter in Sina's book. I think it will save you a lot of wasted time doing nonsensical rituals created by a maniac. Instead of saying you are a radical Muslim, why don't you show us the virtuous truth here by exposing what Ali Sina and MA khan say about Islam. Are you up to it? Are you willing not to put your head in the sand and just waste your life away believing a lie? Are you? Show us sister. Show us. Finally, I like to quote the ever great human being Ayesha Ahmed and what she said about Islam and good Muslims like yourself: "Your brain is like a donkey. Islam is like a Mosque. You can ride your donkey anywhere. But when you go to the mosque, you park your donkey outside.". what a great analogy.

Name: another tamil ex-muslim
Date: Friday January 23, 2009
Time: 05:16:50 -0500


We can at the most write in the web sites like this.We can not speak out our thoughts in public. Happy to know that book like this tamil edition is published. When I was in USA I got the English edition. Very well written. I am yet to read the Tamil edition.It is difficult to get the book here in India. There are good number of fanatic muslim people in Tamilnadu, India. If we openly discuss this with others our life will be in danger. It is really unbelievable to know that the book has been translated in Tamil. Congrats Mona!

Name: Fathima Banu
Date: Tuesday February 17, 2009
Time: 10:38:29 -0500


I am now living in Lyon. My parents are still in Karaikal (Pondicherry), India. Only after coming here and experiencing the outside world, I have started realizing the stupidity of believing Mohammad. I have recently divorced my muslim husband, who could not be reformed. All educated tamil muslim women should leave islam. I realize the greatness of the tolerant tamil culture now and regret that I was brainwashed by the elders in the community.

Hit Counter